by MARCPELLETIER » Thu Jul 13, 2006 11:49 pm
I like the Garabito/Young platoon, but Clark, for a cheaper price, will do a job as good as the platoon. Garabito's card vs rhp is only slightly better than Clark, and his card vs lhp sucks. Given that Young as a high injury (at 8), Garabito will likely see some actions vs lefty pitching. Garabito can also make 15 games. So the overall combo is cheaper and perhaps better with Clark alone (a 600+ PA).
I definitively agree that I would not use Clark as a cf, though. A fine DH for PEtco, but not a cf (in my opinion).
I disagree with Francoeur being a waste. 50% of the divisional pitching has left-handed pitching.
Your biggest problem is a bench too crowded (probably because you wanted to keep your hand on many players). In my opinion, Snow, Garabito and perhaps Young (for a cheaper bench player) should go away. One SP should be disregarded as well. With the extramoney, I would better the offensive talent in the outfield.
For this reason, I am not sure I would keep Taveras. There are so many Petco options for cf, there must be a better offensive cf out there.
I think that Figgins is overpriced (and overestimated), except for injury-prone teams, which your team is not. His best position is at 3rd base, but you already have Wright.