I wasn't going to say anything but I can't imagine a team with either outfield winning anything; .500 might be a struggle. So my suppressed original answer was: none of the above.
Here's a team with Sheckard and Flood that won the division. Of course, it still finished last in the league in offense. And the next time I used Sheckard he hit .197 with and OBP of .279 in a full season.