Round One 1. Red Sox - Hank Aaron 2. Senators - Mickey Mantle 3. Phillies - Luis Aparicio 4. Dodgers - Rod Carew 5. Orioles - Jim Fregosi 6. Cubs - Al Kaline 7. Pirates - Harmon Killebrew 8. Mets - Norm Cash 9. Cardinals - Wilbur Wood 10. Reds - Joe Horlen, SP 11. Giants - Dick McAuliffe 12. Athletics - Felipe Alou
Round Two 1. Red Sox - Fred Gladding 2. Senators - Hoyt Wilhelm 3. Phillies - John Hiller 4. Dodgers - Ruben Amaro 5. Orioles - Don McMahon 6. Cubs - Tony Olivia 7. Pirates - Eddie Mathews 8. Mets - Stu Miller 9. Cardinals - Jim Bouton 10. Reds - Joe Morgan 11. Giants - Dennis Bennett 12. Athletics - Pete Ward
Round Three 1. Red Sox - Tom Burgmeier 2. Senators - Joe Torre 3. Phillies - Ken Johnson 4. Dodgers - Roy White 5. Orioles - Bill Freehan 6. Cubs - Jim Kaat 7. Pirates - Johnny Roseboro 8. Mets - Ron Perranoski 9. Cardinals - Mike Cuellar 10. Reds - Duke Sims 11. Giants - Chico Salmon 12. Athletics - Denis Menke
Round Four 1. Red Sox - Wayne Causey 2. Senators - Dean Chance 3. Phillies - Cesar Tovar 4. Dodgers - Ray Oyler 5. Orioles - Horace Clarke 6. Cubs - Larry Sherry 7. Pirates - Sonny Siebert 8. Mets Willie Horton 9. Cardinals Eddie Fisher 10. Reds Tommy Harper 11. Giants - Gene Michael 12. Athletics - Lindy McDaniel
Round Five 1. Red Sox - Clyde Wright 2. Senators - Phil Niekro 3. Phillies - Gates Brown 4. Dodgers - Al Worthington 5. Orioles - Walt Williams 6. Cubs -Cecil Upshaw 7. Pirates - Ted Uhlaender 8. Mets - Denny McLain 9. Cardinals - Bob "The Human Vacuum Cleaner" Aspromonte 10. Reds - Bubba Morton 11. Giants - Bob Priddy 12. Athletics - Al Downing