ANDY'S ALTERNATE HISTORY 17.0

Looks like I deal with the Naps and Red Sox.

I'll trade Cunningham to the Naps since they had the worse record last season.

I'll deal Uhle to the Red Sox for Jim's 3rd since they had the best record in the league.

Is that OK with the recipients and the Commish?

Works for me, thanks Eric!

yes go for it

ANDY'S ALT17.0 Season #2 PREP

ROUND 1
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Kiki Cuyler OF
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Garland Braxton SP
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Heinie Manush OF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Red Lucas SP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Harry Rice OF
6. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Travis Jackson SS
7. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) - Bob Meusel LF
8. (BOS-Les Bell, BKN-George Grantham, STL-Pie Traynor, SLB-Firpo Marberry)
9.
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - (from PHA) - Taylor Douthit OF
2. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - (from NYG) - Joe Sewell SS (sort of...)
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Riggs Stephenson LF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Rip Collins, RP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Huck Betts RP (aka wasted pick)
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) - Ed Rommell RP
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Dutch Henry RP ONLY (another wasted pick)
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -Bibb Falk OF
9. (BOS-Bill Burwell, BKN-Mike Cvengros, STL-Johnny Morrison, SLB-Shovel Hodge)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Jose Acosta RP
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Phil Collins P
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Bob W Clark RP
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (DET(fromBOS), BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICK SELECTIONS
BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -1 GA - Eddie Brown OF/1B, Heinie Manush OF, Riggs Stephenson LF, Bob W Clark RP
BOSTON RED SOX (cf17)- 1 GA - Topper Rigney, Les Bell 3b, Bill Burwell RP,
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Andy High 2b, George Grantham 1b, Mike Cvengros RP,
CHICAGO CUBS - (drfreeze49) - 0 GA - Gabby Hartnett C and Hack Wilson CF, Ed Rommell RP
CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - 1 GA - Ted Lyons SP, Travis Jackson SS, Dutch Henry RP
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Musial6) - 1 GA - Lew Fonseca 1B, Harry Rice OF, Huck Betts RP
DETROIT TIGERS - (emart) -1 GA - Lu Blue 1B, Red Lucas SP, Rip Collins, RP
NEW YORK GIANTS - (andy) - 1 GA - Bill Terry 1b, Garland Braxton SP, Taylor Douthit OF, Phil Collins P
NEW YORK YANKEES - (boog)- 1 GA - Lou Gehrig 1B,
PHILADELPHIA A's - (ironwill1) - 1 GA - Bing Miller OF, Kiki Cuyler OF, Joe Sewell SS, Jose Acosta RP
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (carr20) - 1 GA - Jim Bottomley 1b, Pie Traynor 3b, Johnny Morrison RP
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (rookssa1958) - 1 GA - Goose Goslin OF, Firpo Marberry SP, Shovel Hodge RP,

Adams, Sparky 2 5 IF
Barnhart, Clyde 2 4 OF
Bengough, Benny 2 5 C
Benton, Larry 2 5 SP
Berg, Moe 2 6 C
Blake, Sheriff 2 6 SP
Bluege, Ossie 2 6 3B
Bush, Guy 2 8 SP
Cunningham, Bill 2 3
Deberry, Joe 2 2 SP
Decatur, Art 2 3 SP
Donohue, Pete 2 5 SP
Durst, Cedric 2 4 OF/1B
Elliott, Jumbo 2 5 SP
Fisher, Showboat 2 5 OF
Fothergill, Bob 'Fats' 2 5 OF
French, Walter 2 4 OF
Gazella, Mike 2 4 3B
Genewich, Joe 2 4 SP
Gooch, Johnny 2 5 C
Hale, Sammy 2 4 1B/3B
Harriss, Slim 2 4 SP
Johnson, Syl 2 7 SP/RP
Kamm, Willie 2 5 3B
Klugmann, Joe 2 3 IF
Kolp, Ray 2 5 SP
Leach, Freddy 2 5 OF/1B
Lutzke, Rube 2 3 3B
Matthews, Wid 2 3 OF
McCurdy, Harry 2 5 C
McManus, Marty 2 5 3B/IF
McMillan, Norm 2 4 3B
Mitchell, Johnny 2 3 SS
Mokan, Johnny 2 3 OF
Moore, Eddie 2 5 IF
Myatt, Glenn 2 6 C
Neis, Bernie 2 3 OF
Ogden, Curly 2 3 SP
Osborne, Tiny 2 3 SP
Pipgras, George 2 5 SP
Prothro, Doc 2 3 3B
Richbourg, Lance 2 5 OF
Root, Charlie 2 7 SP
Sand, Heinie 2 4 SS
Schulte, Johnny 2 5 C
Sewell, Luke 2 7 C
Shaute, Joe 2 5 SP
Sheely, Earl 2 4 1B
Smith, Bob 2 6 SP
Stewart, Lefty 2 5 SP
Summa, Homer 2 4 OF
Tavener, Jackie 2 4 SS
Taylor, Zack 2 5 C
Thompson, Frank E. 2 2 3B/2B
Thurston, Sloppy 2 5 SP
Walberg, Rube 2 6 SP
Whitehill, Earl 2 6 SP
Wilson, Jimmie 2 7 C
Zahniser, Paul 2 4 SP

Musial6 and I need to agree on a trade involving Cunningham before I pick.

Musial6 and I need to agree on a trade involving Cunningham before I pick.

I'll give you my sixth round pick

Musial6 and I need to agree on a trade involving Cunningham before I pick.

I'll give you my sixth round pick

Then you take Uhle, and CF17 can have Cunningham since he offered a 3rd rounder. I won't be picking in the 6th round.

ANDY'S ALT17.0 Season #2 PREP

ROUND 1
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Kiki Cuyler OF
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Garland Braxton SP
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Heinie Manush OF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Red Lucas SP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Harry Rice OF
6. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Travis Jackson SS
7. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) - Bob Meusel LF
8. (BOS-Les Bell, BKN-George Grantham, STL-Pie Traynor, SLB-Firpo Marberry)
9.
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - (from PHA) - Taylor Douthit OF
2. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - (from NYG) - Joe Sewell SS (sort of...)
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Riggs Stephenson LF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Rip Collins, RP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Huck Betts RP (aka wasted pick)
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) - Ed Rommell RP
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Dutch Henry RP ONLY (another wasted pick)
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -Bibb Falk OF
9. (BOS-Bill Burwell, BKN-Mike Cvengros, STL-Johnny Morrison, SLB-Shovel Hodge)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Jose Acosta RP
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Phil Collins P
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Bob W Clark RP
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Mike Gazella 3B
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (DET(fromBOS), BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) -
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICK SELECTIONS
BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -1 GA - Eddie Brown OF/1B, Heinie Manush OF, Riggs Stephenson LF, Bob W Clark RP
BOSTON RED SOX (cf17)- 1 GA - Topper Rigney, Les Bell 3b, Bill Burwell RP,
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Andy High 2b, George Grantham 1b, Mike Cvengros RP,
CHICAGO CUBS - (drfreeze49) - 0 GA - Gabby Hartnett C and Hack Wilson CF, Ed Rommell RP
CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - 1 GA - Ted Lyons SP, Travis Jackson SS, Dutch Henry RP
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Musial6) - 1 GA - Lew Fonseca 1B, Harry Rice OF, Huck Betts RP
DETROIT TIGERS - (emart) -1 GA - Lu Blue 1B, Red Lucas SP, Rip Collins, RP, Mike Gazella 3B
NEW YORK GIANTS - (andy) - 1 GA - Bill Terry 1b, Garland Braxton SP, Taylor Douthit OF, Phil Collins P
NEW YORK YANKEES - (boog)- 1 GA - Lou Gehrig 1B,
PHILADELPHIA A's - (ironwill1) - 1 GA - Bing Miller OF, Kiki Cuyler OF, Joe Sewell SS, Jose Acosta RP
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (carr20) - 1 GA - Jim Bottomley 1b, Pie Traynor 3b, Johnny Morrison RP
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (rookssa1958) - 1 GA - Goose Goslin OF, Firpo Marberry SP, Shovel Hodge RP,

Adams, Sparky 2 5 IF
Barnhart, Clyde 2 4 OF
Bengough, Benny 2 5 C
Benton, Larry 2 5 SP
Berg, Moe 2 6 C
Blake, Sheriff 2 6 SP
Bluege, Ossie 2 6 3B
Bush, Guy 2 8 SP
Cunningham, Bill 2 3
Deberry, Joe 2 2 SP
Decatur, Art 2 3 SP
Donohue, Pete 2 5 SP
Durst, Cedric 2 4 OF/1B
Elliott, Jumbo 2 5 SP
Fisher, Showboat 2 5 OF
Fothergill, Bob 'Fats' 2 5 OF
French, Walter 2 4 OF
Genewich, Joe 2 4 SP
Gooch, Johnny 2 5 C
Hale, Sammy 2 4 1B/3B
Harriss, Slim 2 4 SP
Johnson, Syl 2 7 SP/RP
Kamm, Willie 2 5 3B
Klugmann, Joe 2 3 IF
Kolp, Ray 2 5 SP
Leach, Freddy 2 5 OF/1B
Lutzke, Rube 2 3 3B
Matthews, Wid 2 3 OF
McCurdy, Harry 2 5 C
McManus, Marty 2 5 3B/IF
McMillan, Norm 2 4 3B
Mitchell, Johnny 2 3 SS
Mokan, Johnny 2 3 OF
Moore, Eddie 2 5 IF
Myatt, Glenn 2 6 C
Neis, Bernie 2 3 OF
Ogden, Curly 2 3 SP
Osborne, Tiny 2 3 SP
Pipgras, George 2 5 SP
Prothro, Doc 2 3 3B
Richbourg, Lance 2 5 OF
Root, Charlie 2 7 SP
Sand, Heinie 2 4 SS
Schulte, Johnny 2 5 C
Sewell, Luke 2 7 C
Shaute, Joe 2 5 SP
Sheely, Earl 2 4 1B
Smith, Bob 2 6 SP
Stewart, Lefty 2 5 SP
Summa, Homer 2 4 OF
Tavener, Jackie 2 4 SS
Taylor, Zack 2 5 C
Thompson, Frank E. 2 2 3B/2B
Thurston, Sloppy 2 5 SP
Walberg, Rube 2 6 SP
Whitehill, Earl 2 6 SP
Wilson, Jimmie 2 7 C
Zahniser, Paul 2 4 SP

Musial6 and I need to agree on a trade involving Cunningham before I pick.

I'll give you my sixth round pick

Then you take Uhle, and CF17 can have Cunningham since he offered a 3rd rounder. I won't be picking in the 6th round.

Works for me

ANDY'S ALT17.0 Season #2 PREP

ROUND 1
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Kiki Cuyler OF
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Garland Braxton SP
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Heinie Manush OF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Red Lucas SP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Harry Rice OF
6. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Travis Jackson SS
7. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) - Bob Meusel LF
8. (BOS-Les Bell, BKN-George Grantham, STL-Pie Traynor, SLB-Firpo Marberry)
9.
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - (from PHA) - Taylor Douthit OF
2. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - (from NYG) - Joe Sewell SS (sort of...)
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Riggs Stephenson LF
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Rip Collins, RP
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Huck Betts RP (aka wasted pick)
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) - Ed Rommell RP
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - Dutch Henry RP ONLY (another wasted pick)
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -Bibb Falk OF
9. (BOS-Bill Burwell, BKN-Mike Cvengros, STL-Johnny Morrison, SLB-Shovel Hodge)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) - Jose Acosta RP
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) - Phil Collins P
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) - Bob W Clark RP
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) - Mike Gazella 3B
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - Charlie Root SP
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) - Bernie Nels OF
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (DET(fromBOS), BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - PASS
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - PASS
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. PHILADELPHIA A's (ironwill1) -
2. NEW YORK GIANTS (andy) -
3. BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -
4. DETROIT TIGERS (emart) -
5. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Musial6) - PASS
6. CHICAGO CUBS (drfreeze) -
7. CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (boog) -
9. (BOS, BKN, STL, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICK SELECTIONS
BOSTON BRAVES (FALCON29) -1 GA - Eddie Brown OF/1B, Heinie Manush OF, Riggs Stephenson LF, Bob W Clark RP
BOSTON RED SOX (cf17)- 1 GA - Topper Rigney, Les Bell 3b, Bill Burwell RP,
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Andy High 2b, George Grantham 1b, Mike Cvengros RP,
CHICAGO CUBS - (drfreeze49) - 0 GA - Gabby Hartnett C and Hack Wilson CF, Ed Rommell RP, Bernie Nels OF
CHICAGO WHITE SOX (wahoo) - 1 GA - Ted Lyons SP, Travis Jackson SS, Dutch Henry RP
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Musial6) - 1 GA - Lew Fonseca 1B, Harry Rice OF, Huck Betts RP, Charlie Root SP
DETROIT TIGERS - (emart) -1 GA - Lu Blue 1B, Red Lucas SP, Rip Collins, RP, Mike Gazella 3B
NEW YORK GIANTS - (andy) - 1 GA - Bill Terry 1b, Garland Braxton SP, Taylor Douthit OF, Phil Collins P
NEW YORK YANKEES - (boog)- 1 GA - Lou Gehrig 1B,
PHILADELPHIA A's - (ironwill1) - 1 GA - Bing Miller OF, Kiki Cuyler OF, Joe Sewell SS, Jose Acosta RP
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (carr20) - 1 GA - Jim Bottomley 1b, Pie Traynor 3b, Johnny Morrison RP
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (rookssa1958) - 1 GA - Goose Goslin OF, Firpo Marberry SP, Shovel Hodge RP,

Adams, Sparky 2 5 IF
Barnhart, Clyde 2 4 OF
Bengough, Benny 2 5 C
Benton, Larry 2 5 SP
Berg, Moe 2 6 C
Blake, Sheriff 2 6 SP
Bluege, Ossie 2 6 3B
Bush, Guy 2 8 SP
Cunningham, Bill 2 3
Deberry, Joe 2 2 SP
Decatur, Art 2 3 SP
Donohue, Pete 2 5 SP
Durst, Cedric 2 4 OF/1B
Elliott, Jumbo 2 5 SP
Fisher, Showboat 2 5 OF
Fothergill, Bob 'Fats' 2 5 OF
French, Walter 2 4 OF
Genewich, Joe 2 4 SP
Gooch, Johnny 2 5 C
Hale, Sammy 2 4 1B/3B
Harriss, Slim 2 4 SP
Johnson, Syl 2 7 SP/RP
Kamm, Willie 2 5 3B
Klugmann, Joe 2 3 IF
Kolp, Ray 2 5 SP
Leach, Freddy 2 5 OF/1B
Lutzke, Rube 2 3 3B
Matthews, Wid 2 3 OF
McCurdy, Harry 2 5 C
McManus, Marty 2 5 3B/IF
McMillan, Norm 2 4 3B
Mitchell, Johnny 2 3 SS
Mokan, Johnny 2 3 OF
Moore, Eddie 2 5 IF
Myatt, Glenn 2 6 C
Ogden, Curly 2 3 SP
Osborne, Tiny 2 3 SP
Pipgras, George 2 5 SP
Prothro, Doc 2 3 3B
Richbourg, Lance 2 5 OF
Sand, Heinie 2 4 SS
Schulte, Johnny 2 5 C
Sewell, Luke 2 7 C
Shaute, Joe 2 5 SP
Sheely, Earl 2 4 1B
Smith, Bob 2 6 SP
Stewart, Lefty 2 5 SP
Summa, Homer 2 4 OF
Tavener, Jackie 2 4 SS
Taylor, Zack 2 5 C
Thompson, Frank E. 2 2 3B/2B
Thurston, Sloppy 2 5 SP
Walberg, Rube 2 6 SP
Whitehill, Earl 2 6 SP
Wilson, Jimmie 2 7 C
Zahniser, Paul 2 4 SP

Emart is a lot kinder than I am.

Bernie Neis please