- Posts: 283
- Joined: Thu Sep 13, 2012 11:44 am
genegrid wrote:we went through this on page 11 of the thread. One hitter for each hitting 1/2 team and one piitcher for each pitching 1/2 team. I questioned Ruth going to BOS hitting team but he played over 100 games in the field for the Red Sox. He was not just a pitcher so he was eligible as Bos hitter, this has been clarified 3-4 times.
But look for surprises. I found Hornsby played a few games for the Browns as player/coach in the 30's so I got him as an Orioles hitter.
Actually we didn't cover the issue of one hitter per hitting 1/2 team -- we only covered whether or not Ruth was a hitter for the Red Sox. We didn't address the issue of whether or not the Red Sox could then pick Ted Williams as their second ATG hitter.
Players like Hornsby and Al Simmons are good pickups for some teams, having played a long time and for a bunch of teams.