ANDY'S ALTERNATE HISTORY 3.0

Do I have to pick reggie Harris? I'd much rather have a supplemental pick between rounds 1-2


IMO. This would be a nice rule for future ALTs (if you hate your franchise pick , you can have a supplemental; however, I'd push it back to the 9th pick of the 2nd round)

I’m trying to follow precedent. This is how we’ve done it before.

FRANCHISE PLAYER SELECTIONS
BOSTON RED SOX (andycummings) - 0 GA - Pedro Martinez SP
LOS ANGELES DODGERS (bontomn) - 1 GA -
CHICAGO WHITE SOX (schwabdude) - 2 GA -
CHICAGO CUBS (cf17) - 0 GA - NO SELECTION
CINCINNATI REDS (majicmg) - 1 GA - Reggie Sanders OF
CLEVELAND INDIANS (tcochran) - 0 GA - Manny Ramirez OF
DETROIT TIGERS (fraank123) - 1 GA - Doug Brocail RP
NEW YORK GIANTS (carr20) - 1 GA - Jeff Kent 2B
NEW YORK YANKEES (dharmabums) - 2 GA - Alex Rodriguez SS/3B
OAKLAND A'S (CTStough) - 2 GA - Reggie Harris RP
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (rburgh) - 1 GA - Jim Edmonds CF
MINNESOTA TWINS (george barnard) - 2 GA - Chuck Knoblauch 2B


Baerga, Carlos 16 17 3B CLE
Lofton, Kenny 16 17 CF CLE
Thome, Jim 16 17 3B/1B CLE CWS
Thomas, Frank 16 17 1B CWS
Fryman, Travis 16 17 3B DET
Mondesi, Raul 16 17 RF LA
Piazza, Mike 16 17 C LA
Beck, Rod 16 17 RP NYG
Nen, Robb 16 17 RP NYG
Brosius, Scott 16 17 3B/1B NYY
Mussina, Mike 16 17 SP NYY
Nelson, Jeff 16 17 RP NYY
Williams, Bernie 16 17 CF NYY
Harris, Reggie 16 17 RP OAK
Howard, Steve 16 16 OF OAK
Vina, Fernando 16 17 2B STL
Vaughn, Mo 16 17 1B
Abbott, Paul 16 17 SP/RP
Alou, Moises 16 17 OF
Anderson, Brian 16 17 SP
Anderson, Garret 16 17 OF
Bagwell, Jeff 16 17 1B
Benavides, Freddie 16 16 IF
Benitez, Armando 16 17 RP
Berry, Sean 16 17 3b/1b
Boone, Bret 16 17 2B
Castilla, Vinny 16 17 3b
Cirillo, Jeff 16 17 3B
Conine, Jeff 16 17 1B/LF
Cordero, Wil 16 17 LF/SS
Delgado, Carlos 16 17 1B
Deshields, Delino 16 17 2B
Everett, Carl 16 17 CF/RF
Fassero, Jeff 16 17 SP
Floyd, Cliff 16 17 1b
Frazier, Lou 16 17 OF/1b
Gonzalez, Luis 16 17 LF
Green, Shawn 16 17 OF
Hamilton, Joey 16 17 SP
Henry, Butch 16 17 SP/RP
Henry, Doug 16 17 RP
Heredia, Gil 16 17 SP/RP
Hoffman, Trevor 16 17 RP
Holmes, Darren 16 17 RP
Hundley, Todd 16 17 C
Johnson, Charles 16 17 C
Jones, Chipper 16 17 3B
Lansing, Mike 16 17 2b
Lopez, Javy 16 17 C
Martin, Al 16 17 LF
Pichardo, Hippolito 16 17 SP
Rhodes, Arthur 16 17 RP
Rodriguez, Ivan 16 17 C
Rojas, Mel 16 17 RP
Rueter, Kirk 16 17 SP
Salmon, Tim 16 17 RF
Sanders, Scott 16 17 RP
Scott, Tim 16 17 RP
Sele, Aaron 16 17 SP
Shaw, Jeff 16 17 RP
Sprague, Ed 16 17 3b/1b
Trachsel, Steve 16 17 SP
White, Rondell 16 17 LF
Wilson, Dan 16 17 C
Young, Eric 16 17 2B

Hold up just a second guys - I don't think Castilla should be on this draft list.
He was on my team in Season 15.

FRANCHISE PLAYER SELECTIONS
BOSTON RED SOX (andycummings) - 0 GA - Pedro Martinez SP
LOS ANGELES DODGERS (bontomn) - 1 GA - Mike Piazza C
CHICAGO WHITE SOX (schwabdude) - 2 GA -
CHICAGO CUBS (cf17) - 0 GA - NO SELECTION
CINCINNATI REDS (majicmg) - 1 GA - Reggie Sanders OF
CLEVELAND INDIANS (tcochran) - 0 GA - Manny Ramirez OF
DETROIT TIGERS (fraank123) - 1 GA - Doug Brocail RP
NEW YORK GIANTS (carr20) - 1 GA - Jeff Kent 2B
NEW YORK YANKEES (dharmabums) - 2 GA - Alex Rodriguez SS/3B
OAKLAND A'S (CTStough) - 2 GA - Reggie Harris RP
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (rburgh) - 1 GA - Jim Edmonds CF
MINNESOTA TWINS (george barnard) - 2 GA - Chuck Knoblauch 2B


Baerga, Carlos 16 17 3B CLE
Lofton, Kenny 16 17 CF CLE
Thome, Jim 16 17 3B/1B CLE CWS
Thomas, Frank 16 17 1B CWS
Fryman, Travis 16 17 3B DET
Mondesi, Raul 16 17 RF LA
Beck, Rod 16 17 RP NYG
Nen, Robb 16 17 RP NYG
Brosius, Scott 16 17 3B/1B NYY
Mussina, Mike 16 17 SP NYY
Nelson, Jeff 16 17 RP NYY
Williams, Bernie 16 17 CF NYY
Harris, Reggie 16 17 RP OAK
Howard, Steve 16 16 OF OAK
Vina, Fernando 16 17 2B STL
Vaughn, Mo 16 17 1B
Abbott, Paul 16 17 SP/RP
Alou, Moises 16 17 OF
Anderson, Brian 16 17 SP
Anderson, Garret 16 17 OF
Bagwell, Jeff 16 17 1B
Benavides, Freddie 16 16 IF
Benitez, Armando 16 17 RP
Berry, Sean 16 17 3b/1b
Boone, Bret 16 17 2B
Castilla, Vinny 16 17 3b
Cirillo, Jeff 16 17 3B
Conine, Jeff 16 17 1B/LF
Cordero, Wil 16 17 LF/SS
Delgado, Carlos 16 17 1B
Deshields, Delino 16 17 2B
Everett, Carl 16 17 CF/RF
Fassero, Jeff 16 17 SP
Floyd, Cliff 16 17 1b
Frazier, Lou 16 17 OF/1b
Gonzalez, Luis 16 17 LF
Green, Shawn 16 17 OF
Hamilton, Joey 16 17 SP
Henry, Butch 16 17 SP/RP
Henry, Doug 16 17 RP
Heredia, Gil 16 17 SP/RP
Hoffman, Trevor 16 17 RP
Holmes, Darren 16 17 RP
Hundley, Todd 16 17 C
Johnson, Charles 16 17 C
Jones, Chipper 16 17 3B
Lansing, Mike 16 17 2b
Lopez, Javy 16 17 C
Martin, Al 16 17 LF
Pichardo, Hippolito 16 17 SP
Rhodes, Arthur 16 17 RP
Rodriguez, Ivan 16 17 C
Rojas, Mel 16 17 RP
Rueter, Kirk 16 17 SP
Salmon, Tim 16 17 RF
Sanders, Scott 16 17 RP
Scott, Tim 16 17 RP
Sele, Aaron 16 17 SP
Shaw, Jeff 16 17 RP
Sprague, Ed 16 17 3b/1b
Trachsel, Steve 16 17 SP
White, Rondell 16 17 LF
Wilson, Dan 16 17 C
Young, Eric 16 17 2B

Hold up just a second guys - I don't think Castilla should be on this draft list.
He was on my team in Season 15.

Actually, he shouldn't have been in the Season 15 Pool.

Hold up just a second guys - I don't think Castilla should be on this draft list.
He was on my team in Season 15.

Actually, he shouldn't have been in the Season 15 Pool.

Well crap. So what do we do about that? Since I used a draft pick on him in the S15 draft.

Hold up just a second guys - I don't think Castilla should be on this draft list.
He was on my team in Season 15.

Actually, he shouldn't have been in the Season 15 Pool.

Well crap. So what do we do about that? Since I used a draft pick on him in the S15 draft.

You didn't draft him in Season 15. He wasn't listed in draft-eligible players in Season 15 draft. You must've picked him up post-waivers, since he was accidentally in the Season 15 Player Pool.

You didn't draft him in Season 15. He wasn't listed in draft-eligible players in Season 15 draft. You must've picked him up post-waivers, since he was accidentally in the Season 15 Player Pool.[/quote]

Right. That's what happened. I remember it now. For some reason I thought I'd drafted him, but I remember more clearly now - I was looking for some more power, and I noticed his card was SS eligible.

So my question - how do we handle this? Do I get to keep Castilla? Lose him but get compensation? None of the above?

You got a season's use out of him when he shouldn't have been in the league.
He won't be your property this season. If you want him for this next season, you need to draft him.