Round One
1. Astros - Frank Robinson, OF
2. Athletics - Carl Yastrzemski, OF
3. Phillies - Bob Gibson, P
4. Braves - Joel Horlen, P
5. Indians - Pete Rose, OF/2b
6. Orioles - Vada Pinson, OF
7. Angels - Roberto Clemente, OF
8. Dodgers - Ernie Banks, IF
9. Giants - Duke Snider, OF
10. Yankees - Claude Osteen, SP
11. Tigers - Sammy Taylor C
12. Twins - Bill Mazeroski, 2B
Round Two
1. Astros - Ron Hansen SS
2. Athletics - Hoyt Wilhelm, P
3. Phillies - Bobby Shantz, RP
4. Braves - Rico Petrocelli, SS
5. Indians - Billy Williams, OF
6. Orioles - Johnny Edwards, C
7. Angels - Ron Santo, 3B
8. Dodgers - Jim Brosnan, RP
9. Giants - Leo Cardenas, IF
10. Yankees - Lindy McDaniel, P
11. Tigers - Don Blasingame 2B
12. Twins - Dick Radatz, P
Round Three
1. Astros - Larry Jackson SP
2. Athletics - Sherm Lollar, C
3. Phillies - Bob Friend, SP
4. Braves - Wilbur Wood, RP
5. Indians - Dick Groat, SS
6. Orioles - Ron Hunt, 2B
7. Angels - Bill White, 1B
8. Dodgers - Bill Monbouquette, SP
9. Giants - Julian Javier, 2B
10. Yankees - Jim Hickman, 1B
11. Tigers - Steve Ridzik, P
12. Twins - Alex Grammas, IF
Round Four
1. Astros - Ron Kline, P
2. Athletics - Ken Boyer, 3B
3. Phillies - Tommy Harper, OF
4. Braves - Willie Stargell, OF/1B
5. Indians - Bill Henry, RP
6. Orioles - Dick Schofield, IF
7. Angels - Gary Peters SP
8. Dodgers - Curt Flood, OF
9. Giants - Bob Tillman, C
10. Yankees - John Kennedy, IF
11. Tigers - Johnny Logan, SS
12. Twins - Buddy Schultz, P
Round Five
1. Astros - Gary Geiger, OF
2. Athletics - Jim O’Toole, P
3. Phillies - Chris Cannizzaro, C
4. Braves - Eddie Fisher, P
5. Indians - Jim Maloney, P
6. Orioles - Carl Sawatski, C
7. Angels - Roy Face - RP
8. Dodgers - Smoky Burgess, C
9. Giants
10. Yankees
11. Tigers
12. Twins
1. Astros - Frank Robinson, OF
2. Athletics - Carl Yastrzemski, OF
3. Phillies - Bob Gibson, P
4. Braves - Joel Horlen, P
5. Indians - Pete Rose, OF/2b
6. Orioles - Vada Pinson, OF
7. Angels - Roberto Clemente, OF
8. Dodgers - Ernie Banks, IF
9. Giants - Duke Snider, OF
10. Yankees - Claude Osteen, SP
11. Tigers - Sammy Taylor C
12. Twins - Bill Mazeroski, 2B
Round Two
1. Astros - Ron Hansen SS
2. Athletics - Hoyt Wilhelm, P
3. Phillies - Bobby Shantz, RP
4. Braves - Rico Petrocelli, SS
5. Indians - Billy Williams, OF
6. Orioles - Johnny Edwards, C
7. Angels - Ron Santo, 3B
8. Dodgers - Jim Brosnan, RP
9. Giants - Leo Cardenas, IF
10. Yankees - Lindy McDaniel, P
11. Tigers - Don Blasingame 2B
12. Twins - Dick Radatz, P
Round Three
1. Astros - Larry Jackson SP
2. Athletics - Sherm Lollar, C
3. Phillies - Bob Friend, SP
4. Braves - Wilbur Wood, RP
5. Indians - Dick Groat, SS
6. Orioles - Ron Hunt, 2B
7. Angels - Bill White, 1B
8. Dodgers - Bill Monbouquette, SP
9. Giants - Julian Javier, 2B
10. Yankees - Jim Hickman, 1B
11. Tigers - Steve Ridzik, P
12. Twins - Alex Grammas, IF
Round Four
1. Astros - Ron Kline, P
2. Athletics - Ken Boyer, 3B
3. Phillies - Tommy Harper, OF
4. Braves - Willie Stargell, OF/1B
5. Indians - Bill Henry, RP
6. Orioles - Dick Schofield, IF
7. Angels - Gary Peters SP
8. Dodgers - Curt Flood, OF
9. Giants - Bob Tillman, C
10. Yankees - John Kennedy, IF
11. Tigers - Johnny Logan, SS
12. Twins - Buddy Schultz, P
Round Five
1. Astros - Gary Geiger, OF
2. Athletics - Jim O’Toole, P
3. Phillies - Chris Cannizzaro, C
4. Braves - Eddie Fisher, P
5. Indians - Jim Maloney, P
6. Orioles - Carl Sawatski, C
7. Angels - Roy Face - RP
8. Dodgers - Smoky Burgess, C
9. Giants
10. Yankees
11. Tigers
12. Twins