Strat-O-Matic Baseball 365

oldmansmith2 wrote:Terry would like you to make a ruling on this. I had Garneau and Plawecki as my preferred picks for my 2nd catcher because I'm rebuilding to start contending again in 2019. When they got picked I of course crossed them off my list and took Hanigan since there was no other catchers with years like Garneau and Plawecki in 19 and 20 left available. Now it looks like Garneau should have been available. I checked with Paul Kiggins who I believe is the only other manager to draft a catcher since Harold's pick and he had no interest in Garneau. I would like to change my Hanigan pick to Garneau if possible.

I'm ok with the switch.

ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - TIMED OUT 5:50 PM EDT

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65: ..........TIMED OUT 8:23pm edt
14. WJS6768: ......... ON THE CLOCK TILL 9:23 pm EDT
16. paul j kiggins
17. dharmabums
18. centerfielder17
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - TIMED OUT 5:50 PM EDT

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... ON THE CLOCK TILL 9:23 pm EDT
16. paul j kiggins
17. dharmabums
18. centerfielder17
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - TIMED OUT 5:50 PM EDT

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... ON THE CLOCK TILL 9:23 pm EDT
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums
18. centerfielder17
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

{{ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - TIMED OUT 5:50 PM EDT

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... TIMED OUT @ 9:23 pm
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums - Tommy Hunter RP CHC
18. centerfielder17
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

{{ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - Ben Paulsen 1B COL

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... TIMED OUT @ 9:23 pm
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums - Tommy Hunter RP CHC
18. centerfielder17
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

oldmansmith2 wrote:Terry would like you to make a ruling on this. I had Garneau and Plawecki as my preferred picks for my 2nd catcher because I'm rebuilding to start contending again in 2019. When they got picked I of course crossed them off my list and took Hanigan since there was no other catchers with years like Garneau and Plawecki in 19 and 20 left available. Now it looks like Garneau should have been available. I checked with Paul Kiggins who I believe is the only other manager to draft a catcher since Harold's pick and he had no interest in Garneau. I would like to change my Hanigan pick to Garneau if possible.

Absolutely, let's make it so!

{{ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Ryan Hanigan C BOS
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - Ben Paulsen 1B COL

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... TIMED OUT @ 9:23 pm
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums - Tommy Hunter RP CHC
18. centerfielder17 - Jason Werth OF
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

{{ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Dustin Garneau C COL
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - Ben Paulsen 1B COL

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... TIMED OUT @ 9:23 pm
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums - Tommy Hunter RP CHC
18. centerfielder17 - Jason Werth OF
19. Hamilton17
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon

{{ROUND 7}}
1. Harold Homers (from fredpaii)-E.Carrera OF TOR
2. tcochran - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
3. Harold Homers -No pick -ROSTER FULL
4. jodynadu - NO PICK - ROSTER
5. timklucinec - Pedro Villareal RP CIN
6. Jerm12 - Nick Franklin
7. Hamilton17 (from beesore) - Jesse Chavez P OAK
8. baseballmike - Tim Cooney SP STL
9. baseball cfo- Luis Avilan RP LAD
10. unctarheel - Mike Pelfrey SP MIN
11. yannick - Eury Perez OF ATL
12. TBeard - Matt Moore SP TB
13. andycummings65 - Seth Smith OF SEA
14. WJS6768 - Brandon Finnegan SP CIN
15. Dr.Publix - NO PICK - ROSTER FULL
16. paul j kiggins: CARLOS PEREZ C LAA
17. dharmabums - Dustin Ackley LF NYY
18. centerfielder17 - Juan Uribe IF
19. Hamilton17 - Preston Tucker OF HOU
20. lev.cohen - Richie Shaffer 3B TB
21. oldmansmith2 - Dustin Garneau C COL
22. Terry101 - David Hernandez RP AZ
23. bigmahon - TIMED OUT 4:50 PM EDT
24. chilliards - Ben Paulsen 1B COL

{{ROUND 8}}
6. Jerm12: TIMED OUT @6:50pm edt
8. baseballmike -Clint Robinson 1B Was
9. baseball cfo: Jordan Pacheco C ARI
13. andycummings65 Anibal Sanchez SP DET
14. WJS6768: ......... TIMED OUT @ 9:23 pm
16. paul j kiggins: OF Brandon Moss STL
17. dharmabums - Tommy Hunter RP CHC
18. centerfielder17 - Jason Werth OF
19. Hamilton17 - JJ Hardy SS BAL
20. lev.cohen
21. oldmansmith2
22. Terry101
23. bigmahon