Page 1 of 2

Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Thu Apr 10, 2014 10:16 am
by Knerrpool
After starting a game, how long does a relief eligible starter have to wait until he can pitch in relief at full strength? Thanks.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Thu Apr 10, 2014 8:30 pm
by Scottbdoug
I havent been able to figure out a way to get a starter to relieve if they are eligible to do so unless i specifically give him a role in the pitching preferences. As for how long it is just as a normal starter would be. That is, if he is a * then its the 4th game after the start, if no * then its the 5th game.

Im not sure whether it matters if hal takes him out early because of a blow out but i dont think it does. Others can correct me if im wrong.

Scott.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sat Apr 12, 2014 12:00 am
by coyote303
I may be wrong, but I didn't think HAL would use someone in relief if they were in the rotation.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sat Apr 12, 2014 12:10 am
by rhonda1957
coyote303 wrote:I may be wrong, but I didn't think HAL would use someone in relief if they were in the rotation.

yeah he will check out these back to back games
http://onlinegames.strat-o-matic.com/game/348867/524
http://onlinegames.strat-o-matic.com/game/348867/530

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sat Apr 12, 2014 3:34 am
by paul8210
Buchholz' relief appearance after starting shows he entered the game as an 'F0'...totally fatigued. He was not assigned to a role and came in to pitch only because HAL made the choice after running out of relievers. I'm guessing he would have entered as an 'F9', despite his previous start a game earlier, had he been assigned to a bullpen role that satisfied the situation.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2014 10:38 am
by coyote303
paul8210 wrote:Buchholz' relief appearance after starting shows he entered the game as an 'F0'...totally fatigued. He was not assigned to a role and came in to pitch only because HAL made the choice after running out of relievers. I'm guessing he would have entered as an 'F9', despite his previous start a game earlier, had he been assigned to a bullpen role that satisfied the situation.


This is an interesting theory. However, Bullpen v2 was written by Bernie when the online game was still on TSN. It is an overlay to the game that simply determines which reliever comes into the game when. I seriously doubt a reliever's fatigue level would be affected by whether or not a he has a bullpen role for any given situation.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2014 1:19 pm
by paul8210
viewtopic.php?f=12&t=635165

Sandy Koufax came into pitch as a LH Specialist against your team, as you recall in your post above. Unlike Clay Buchholz, who was not assigned to a relief role, he entered as an F9 instead of an F0.

So, I'm guessing Koufax entered as an F9 either because:
1) The 60's set is programmed differently from the set that has Clay Buchholz. Perhaps, Koufax came in as an F9 because of custom code (or lack of custom code) and that same custom code doesn't (or does) exist for Buchholz.
2) Koufax was assigned to a relief role and Buchholz was not.
3) Koufax threw only 68 pitches in his previous start and HAL figured that an F9 entry point was appropriate based on number of pitches thrown in previous start.

My guess was #2. I imagine your guess is #1. You're probably right, based on the fact that Bullpen V2 only is used for 1990's and beyond.

So, the answer to the original question is, "It depends on which set you are playing with."

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2014 10:33 pm
by coyote303
You're probably right, based on the fact that Bullpen V2 only is used for 1990's and beyond.


Bullpen V2 is used in all mystery game leagues, including the 60s.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2014 10:25 pm
by paul8210
According to Wikipedia, Bullpen V2 is not used in 60s,70s,80s
http://somonline.wikia.com/wiki/Bullpen_v2

So, when Koufax of the 60's pitched in relief after resting for only two games after his previous start and comes in as an F9 instead of a partial or fully fatigued pitcher, it's either because
1. He's a starter/reliever, rather than just a starter.
2. He was assigned a role as a LH specialist
3. He threw only 68 pitches in his prior start.
4. Bullpen V1 has custom code for just Koufax.

When Buchholz comes in to relieve after starting the previous game because HAL ran out of pitchers, and comes in as an F0, it's either because
1. He is listed as a starter only, so he wasn't assigned a role.
2. He is controlled by Bullpen V2, which has different rules than the Bullpen V1 of the 1960's player set.

Re: Relief after Starting

PostPosted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 12:27 am
by coyote303
paul8210 wrote:According to Wikipedia, Bullpen V2 is not used in 60s,70s,80s
http://somonline.wikia.com/wiki/Bullpen_v2

So, when Koufax of the 60's pitched in relief after resting for only two games after his previous start and comes in as an F9 instead of a partial or fully fatigued pitcher, it's either because
1. He's a starter/reliever, rather than just a starter.
2. He was assigned a role as a LH specialist
3. He threw only 68 pitches in his prior start.
4. Bullpen V1 has custom code for just Koufax.

When Buchholz comes in to relieve after starting the previous game because HAL ran out of pitchers, and comes in as an F0, it's either because
1. He is listed as a starter only, so he wasn't assigned a role.
2. He is controlled by Bullpen V2, which has different rules than the Bullpen V1 of the 1960's player set.


Your wiki page you reference is nearly five years old and quite obsolete.

Before Bullpen V2, you didn't select roles. There were just a very few preassigned roles. Getting relievers to do what you wanted with the original bullpen settings was hopeless and frustrating. Bullpen v2 was (IMHO) the best improvement made to the online game, and I wouldn't play with any set of cards that used the original bullpen.

I will say this one last time (and this time without tact): A pitcher's fatigue rating has nothing to do with whether or not he has a role assigned. Choose to believe otherwise at your own peril.