Mystery Card Tournament - Final 12 Voting

Here are the items I think the final 12 should/need to vote on:

Which set? I say vote for 1st choice (2 points) and 2nd choice (1 point)

Salary Cap. $80M or $100M?

DH: yes or no? You can vote separately by set (e.g., no DH for 60s, but DH for 90s)

Live Draft or Autodraft? If live, I assume the drafting order would be based on the final standings with #1 in points getting the #1 pick, etc. (that is what we did the 2 previous times with live drafts in the mystery tourney finals). We could also do the "live" draft with maybe a 10 round draft on these boards if it is impractical to get all 12 owners online at the same time.

Unique Stadiums (i.e., everyone in the league has to have a different stadium)? Yes or No? If auto draft, probably just let owners pick stadiums based on final standings (1-12), if live draft we could include the stadium as part of the draft.

Repeat Stadiums (can you reuse the stadium from your prior team in that set)? yes or no?

Divisions: random divisions vs. seeded divisions (1/6/7/12; 2/5/8/11; 3/4/9/10)?

Am I missing anything?

Current standings with 8 who have clinched (points/positions still can change based on 90s playoffs):
1. franky35 413
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394
8. TallEd 381
9 ??
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??

1. franky35 - 60s, 90s, 80 mil, DH except not for 60s, live draft, unique stadium, repeat ok, seeded
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394
8. TallEd 381
9 ??
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??

Though I would love a live draft, I almost certainly will not be able to be online when everyone else is. Coordinating all 12 will be impossible, and a draft on the board will take too much time IMO.
Also, the repeat stadiums is something that needed to be made clear before the tournament started because my choice of stadium would have been different in at least 1 possibly 2 leagues.
Everything else, including unique stadiums I'd be fine with voting for.
lastly if I may suggest giving the #1 point getter the tiebreaking vote if that were to be the case.

1. franky35 - 60s, 90s, 80 mil, DH except not for 60s, live draft, unique stadium, repeat ok, seeded
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, autodraft, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
8. TallEd 381
9 ??
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??

Offline
voovits
Posts: 426
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 7:39 pm
Re: Mystery Card Tournament - Final 12 Voting
PostSat May 02, 2015 4:59 pm



1. franky35 - 60s, 90s, 80 mil, DH except not for 60s, live draft, unique stadium, repeat ok, seeded
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, autodraft, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
8. TallEd 381-80's,60's; 80 mil; DH80's no DH 60's; live draft; unique stadium; repeat OK; seeded
9 ??
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??

In view of Voovits comments, if live draft were selected, we would need to figure out a practical way to do a live draft. If everyone can't participate in an actual live draft, then perhaps a 2 round or 4 round, serpentine draft on the message board.

If we end up with a "live" draft, I doubt there is any chance that all 12 owners could actually do it at the same time live. Therefore, I'd suggest a surpentine "live" draft on these boards. I was thinking more like 10 rounds, but would be agreeable to something somewhat less if that is the consensus. It might take a week to get through 10 rounds.

Though I still vote against it, I would support a live draft on the boards. However I would be strongly against any draft clock considering what is at stake for the season. I know when I'm at work I have no internet access and I dont want to rely on a proxy draft list for a season of this magnitude.

If the vote goes for a live draft I agree that it should be done on the message board. Time clock and the use of proxies just isn't right. I am good with limited rounds if that is the consensus. If the vote goes for unique stadiums, that draft should take place on the board or be included as part of the player draft if a live draft is the voted option.

1. franky35 - 60s, 90s, 80 mil, DH except not for 60s, live draft, unique stadium, repeat ok, seeded
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, livedraft on boards, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, autodraft, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
8. TallEd 381-80's,60's; 80 mil; DH80's no DH 60's; live draft; unique stadium; repeat OK; seeded
9 ??
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??

1. franky35 - 60s, 90s, 80 mil, DH except not for 60s, live draft, unique stadium, repeat ok, seeded
2. pushpin76 399
2. jomboy78 399
4. sphilipp8 397 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, livedraft on boards, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
5. GordieHowe 396
6. hallerose 395
7. voovits 394 - 80s, 90s, 80 mil, DH for all, autodraft, any stadium, repeat OK, seeded
8. TallEd 381-80's,60's; 80 mil; DH80's no DH 60's; live draft; unique stadium; repeat OK; seeded
9 RJNewman
10. ??
11. ??
12. ??