19.4 Nominations will open on 7/29

Greetings,

We will start taking nominations for the 19.4 card add on Monday 7/29. That gives everyone 2 weeks to contemplate their potential nomination.

Andy has done some fine work in this forum re potential nominees from pre-2000 seasons. Many others have contributed excellent ideas as well. There are several threads to be found under NO CARD or IMPROVEMENT edition. Please take a look.

Also, please note these slight changes to our usage parameters for nominations from 19.4 forward -

Minimums:
250 AB
100 IP Starters
50 IP Relievers

Thanks,
Bill

Also, please note these slight changes to our usage parameters for nominations from 19.4 forward -

Minimums:
250 AB
100 IP Starters
50 IP Relievers

Thanks,
Bill

Hello Bill. Thanks for all your fine work in getting new cards added.

We all know what an at bat is and what a plate appearance is. While I don't think the difference will affect many nominees, the unintended consequence of using 250 AB instead of 250 PA as the minimum threshold for nominee batters is that such may render ineligible otherwise worthy players who get a lot of walks, HBP and sacs. While I don't think there are many potential nominees who will be affected by the difference between AB & PA, is there some flexibility to use PA instead of AB as the standard for hitters so as not to eliminate potential nominees who don't have 250 AB, but have 250+ PA due to a high number of BB and HBP?

Also, please note these slight changes to our usage parameters for nominations from 19.4 forward -

Minimums:
250 AB
100 IP Starters
50 IP Relievers

Thanks,
Bill

Hello Bill. Thanks for all your fine work in getting new cards added.

We all know what an at bat is and what a plate appearance is. While I don't think the difference will affect many nominees, the unintended consequence of using 250 AB instead of 250 PA as the minimum threshold for nominee batters is that such may render ineligible otherwise worthy players who get a lot of walks, HBP and sacs. While I don't think there are many potential nominees who will be affected by the difference between AB & PA, is there some flexibility to use PA instead of AB as the standard for hitters so as not to eliminate potential nominees who don't have 250 AB, but have 250+ PA due to a high number of BB and HBP?

Thanks!

I'm fine with setting the bar at 250 PA.

Bill

I liked the unintended consequence of 250 ABs over PAs. I certainly do now.

Why all the 2018 cards? We're not even done with that set in 20XX yet. I think these cards should wait their turn.

I liked the unintended consequence of 250 ABs over PAs. I certainly do now.

Agreed. Thinking 300 AB might have been even better.

Why all the 2018 cards? We're not even done with that set in 20XX yet. I think these cards should wait their turn.

The 19.4 cards likely won't make into the set until December (or later). The parameters were established by Strat, as they requested we wait until x.4 to nominate cards from the current set.

Also, there are 3 nominations from 2018, two Cy Young award winners and an MVP. Looks good to me...

Why all the 2018 cards? We're not even done with that set in 20XX yet. I think these cards should wait their turn.

The 19.4 cards likely won't make into the set until December (or later). The parameters were established by Strat, as they requested we wait until x.4 to nominate cards from the current set.

Also, there are 3 nominations from 2018, two Cy Young award winners and an MVP. Looks good to me...

At least that explains the run. Aaron Nola, anyone?

I liked the unintended consequence of 250 ABs over PAs. I certainly do now.

Agreed. Thinking 300 AB might have been even better.

In my mind, the ONLY reason to include cards with few ABs should be to add scrubs, not to search out aberrative cards that don’t represent something close to a full season. We have enough Gates Brown’s and Ken Smith’s. If a player wasn’t good enough or was too injured to produce 300-350 ABs in a given season, do we really need that season?

Instead of using the limits to keep out outliers and aberrations, it looks like we are using the 250 limit to hunt out crazy stat lines from players who are not at all represented by some half or quarter season they lucked into.