- Posts: 1287
- Joined: Wed Feb 06, 2013 8:46 am
Tue Feb 11, 2025 5:31 pm
Please note special rule for the 25.1 ATG card add.
Only players with NO CARD in ATG are eligible!
AL/NL cards from 1876-2023 are eligible for no-card players.
Please note a slight usage adjustment for 2025.
Minimums:
275 PA Hitters
100 IP Starters (S or S/R)
45 IP Relievers
25.1 parameters are as follows.
1. One nomination per member only
2. When we hit 43 unique nominations we will begin voting (after Andy posts card analysis)
3. We will have one poll of 50 cards; the top 25 will be added
4. Next "x" highest vote getters will get another shot in 25.2
Please submit nominations in a 'Year Player Team Position Comments' format.
To be included in the 25.1 poll:
2004 Kevin Millar Boston 1b 38
2008 Milton Bradley TEX 37
1886 Hardy Richardson DTN LF 36
2010 Brian Wilson, RP SFG 26
2000 John Vander Wal PIT OF 29
1879 Paul Hines Providence CF 28
1958 Harry Anderson LF/1b 26
1. 1990 Ben McDonald Bal SP(7) 6L righty ROY-8 2.43 era 1.03 whip 6.7hits/9 0.7 hr/9 nice reverse righty starter 9 year career. Very useful card.
2. 2019 Joey Gallo TEX 253/389/589 L5L lf/cf310(-4) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92621/2019/1/2019
3. 2018 Max Muncy 1b 4e13 3b 4e39 2b 4e16 lf 5 (+2) e3 .263/.391/.582 35 home runs in less than 400 at bats https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92639/2018/1/2018
4. 2022 Wilson Contrares C. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92867/2022/1/2022 Contrares is the highest WAR of any active player not represented in ATG9. 2022 represents his best card in the SOM set.
5. 1894 Mike Griffin OF BRO (when they were known as the Statistics), .357/.466/.485, ops .951, ops+ 137, 39 sb, 78bb/14k, often called the finest CF of the era, scored 123 runs in 108 games, one of 17 players to score 100+ runs in ten seasons (15 in the Hall of Fame)
6. 1876 Jim Devlin Lou SP 30-35 1.56 .97 68 games started 66 complete games (also hit .315 in 298 ab).
7. 1980 Miguel Dilone Cleveland Indians, (LF, CF, RF) Bat - S, WAR 3.0, G-132, 2B-30, 3B-9, SB-61, BA-341, OB-375, SLG-437, OPS - 807 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/33051/1980/4/1980
8. 1983 Greg Gross PHI OF .302/.385/ .761 OPS 17 year vet, key bench player and pinch hitter for 80's Phillies
9. 2008 Geovany Soto C CHC - Won ROTY with a .285avg .364obp 23hr 352b. C2e3 with a -1 arm. 13 year career (7.5 with the Cubs) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1088/2008/1/2008
10. 1940 Debs Garms PIT. Led league in batting with a .355 AVG, looks good vs RHP. .355 BA/.395 OBP/.500 SA. Bats-L BAL-2R 3b-4e25, LF/CF/RF-4(+2)e16 INJ Risk-15, LH--2b- 6.4 3b-2.5 HR-1.7 BB-4 .380/.409/.540 OPS-.948, RH--2b- 8 3b-3.3 HR-2 BB-4 .475/.500/.674 OPS-1.174
11.1971 Joe Grzenda, LHRP, Senators, 5-2 1.92 1.009 3R Career best ERA, WHIP, H9, BB9, SO9, SO/BB ratio. Grzenda was a journeyman lefty specialist and fringe major leaguer, who at the age of 34 put together one magical season. Expansion Senators/Rangers could use a good lefty relief pitcher. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/734732/1670/1/70
12. 2014 Sean Doolitle LRP OAK 0.73 WHIP 89 K's in 63 IP. Would give Oakland a stud lefty to team with righty Eckersley (could opt for the even more dominant 2018 card, but he only had 45 IP that year) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91672/2014/1/2014
13. 1956 Red Wilson DET C .289 AVG .393 OBP .452 SLG 278 PA. Threw out 55.4%, 10% higher than the league average. Would give Postwar Tigers an upgrade at C.
14. 2006 Joel Zumaya. RP Detroit Tigers. 83 IPs with 97 K's, 233 ERA+, 10,5 K per 9ip, 0.6 HR/9, an RP only who can pitch 2/3 innings
15. 1969 Mack Jones MON LF Bats-L Career-high .270 BA, .379 OBP, .488 SLG, 867 OPS, 22 HR & 79 RBI. Darling of the first-year Montreal Expo fans, the left-field bleachers in Jarry Park were nicknamed "Jonesville." He hit the very first HR in a Major League regular season game in Canada and was a major part of making baseball in Montreal a success. 10-year veteran currently has no ATG card, and deserves one badly.
16. 1984 Alejandro Pena, RHSP, Dodgers 12-6 2.48 1.164 Led N.L. in ERA and ShO. Career bests in GS, W, IP, ShO, HR9, K and BB/9. Pena blew out his arm the following year, but reinvented himself as a pretty good relief pitcher.
17. 2012 Brandon Moss OAK 1b-3e27/ rf-3(-1)e9/ lf-3e9 Slashline: 291/.358/.596 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1385/2012/1/2012
18. 2011 Starlin Castro - CHC - SS - Slashline: .307/.341/.432 - League leader in hits with 207 and was an All-Star in his age 21 season (2011). 12 total seasons in the MLB with 1,722 career hits. Key player in the Cubs 'rebuild years' of the 2010s and would add to the Cubs ATG SS options.
19. 1948 Gene Bearden. CLE. LH S/R. Key member of the Tribe’s last championship. Knuckle curve that induced 42 GIDP. 20-7, 2.43 ERA. 229 IP. Completed 15 of his 29 starts. 6 shutouts. Only 9HR allowed. WW2 vet who served honorablty during the war. Played on several service clubs. Made the bigs at age 27. Beat the Red Sox in a 1-game playoff to get his team into the series. Pitched a shutout in Game 3, then saved the clincher. This season was his only shining moment, but it still gleams today.
20. 2011 Mike Adams, TEX, RH R1/C0, 3L. Helps TEX bullpen. No BP singles either way.
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/90666/2011/1/2011
21. 1989 Mike Bielecki Cubs SP* 18-7 3.14 CYA-9 his best season i think 14 years no card i could find https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/30869/1690/1/90
22. 1883 Tony Mullane, St. Louis, SP, throws both (but mostly righty) 35-15, 2.19 0.968. Career bests in W%, WHIP, H9, HR9, & BB9. Near career bests in W & ERA. Won 30+ games 5 straight seasons. Mullane’s 284 career wins are 4th most among pitchers NOT in the HOF (behind Roger Clemens at 354, Bobby Mathews at 297 and Tommy John at 288). Having no card adds insult to injury.
23. 2004 Carlos Lee, CWS, Bats-R, E Balance, LF-4(+1)e0, .305/.366/.525, 31 HR, 99 RBI, 2099 Games-No Card, CWS-exp is VERY light at LF
24.1925 Ben Paschal Yankees. 1028 OPS Right handed 2L Left/Center/Right 3 on Max. Pinch hitter and 4th Outfielder to the great Yankee teams.
25. 1994 Bob Hamelin, DH/1B, Kansas City ROY - Left Handed one year wonder, slashed .282/.388/.599, 25 doubles, 1 triple, 24 homers in just 375 plate appearances https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3211/1690/1/90
26. 1987 Randy Ready, 3B/2B/LF, SD Padres, RHH, 2L, .309/.423/.520. Infielder with a pretty sick card, clutch neutral, price probably moderated by shaky glove. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/839926/1680/1/80
27. 1964 Jim Pagliaroni, C, PIT, RHH, E, .295/.383/.454. Average defense and arm, given a 1 INJ rating in Superstar '60s set (unusual for a catcher) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/39219/1660/1/60
28. 1930 Smead Jolly ' The Arkansas Assassin' bats left .313 Batting average with193 hits 38 doubles 12 triples 16 home runs and 116 RBI's 'Smead wasn't much of a guy with the glove but he was murder with the wood.'
29. 2016 Masahiro Tanaka, SP, NY Yankees, RHP. 14-4 in 199 IP. 165 Ks. 3.07 ERA vs league averge 4.20. Excellent 140 ERA+. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/500013/2016/1/2016
30. 2004 Brandon inge Det ---We can always use Catchers / Utility players https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/551/1700/1/120
31.2023 Felix Bautista, Baltimore Orioles, RP, 8-2, 1>48 ERA, 33 Saves, AS, 11th in Cy Young voting. O's team can use more good closers. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/100045/2023/1/2023
32. 2021 Brandon Woodruff, MIL, RHP, Brewers need more SPs! 2.56 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, 211 K
33. 2004 Oliver Perez 2.98 ERA 1.15 WHIP. 196 IP, 239 SO. Lefty, 1L. [20-year career, needs a card]
34. 2021 Kyle Schwarber, BOS, His best offensive card, 32 HR, .266/.374/.554, .928 OPS
35.
Only players with NO CARD in ATG are eligible!
AL/NL cards from 1876-2023 are eligible for no-card players.
Please note a slight usage adjustment for 2025.
Minimums:
275 PA Hitters
100 IP Starters (S or S/R)
45 IP Relievers
25.1 parameters are as follows.
1. One nomination per member only
2. When we hit 43 unique nominations we will begin voting (after Andy posts card analysis)
3. We will have one poll of 50 cards; the top 25 will be added
4. Next "x" highest vote getters will get another shot in 25.2
Please submit nominations in a 'Year Player Team Position Comments' format.
To be included in the 25.1 poll:
2004 Kevin Millar Boston 1b 38
2008 Milton Bradley TEX 37
1886 Hardy Richardson DTN LF 36
2010 Brian Wilson, RP SFG 26
2000 John Vander Wal PIT OF 29
1879 Paul Hines Providence CF 28
1958 Harry Anderson LF/1b 26
1. 1990 Ben McDonald Bal SP(7) 6L righty ROY-8 2.43 era 1.03 whip 6.7hits/9 0.7 hr/9 nice reverse righty starter 9 year career. Very useful card.
2. 2019 Joey Gallo TEX 253/389/589 L5L lf/cf310(-4) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92621/2019/1/2019
3. 2018 Max Muncy 1b 4e13 3b 4e39 2b 4e16 lf 5 (+2) e3 .263/.391/.582 35 home runs in less than 400 at bats https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92639/2018/1/2018
4. 2022 Wilson Contrares C. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/92867/2022/1/2022 Contrares is the highest WAR of any active player not represented in ATG9. 2022 represents his best card in the SOM set.
5. 1894 Mike Griffin OF BRO (when they were known as the Statistics), .357/.466/.485, ops .951, ops+ 137, 39 sb, 78bb/14k, often called the finest CF of the era, scored 123 runs in 108 games, one of 17 players to score 100+ runs in ten seasons (15 in the Hall of Fame)
6. 1876 Jim Devlin Lou SP 30-35 1.56 .97 68 games started 66 complete games (also hit .315 in 298 ab).
7. 1980 Miguel Dilone Cleveland Indians, (LF, CF, RF) Bat - S, WAR 3.0, G-132, 2B-30, 3B-9, SB-61, BA-341, OB-375, SLG-437, OPS - 807 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/33051/1980/4/1980
8. 1983 Greg Gross PHI OF .302/.385/ .761 OPS 17 year vet, key bench player and pinch hitter for 80's Phillies
9. 2008 Geovany Soto C CHC - Won ROTY with a .285avg .364obp 23hr 352b. C2e3 with a -1 arm. 13 year career (7.5 with the Cubs) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1088/2008/1/2008
10. 1940 Debs Garms PIT. Led league in batting with a .355 AVG, looks good vs RHP. .355 BA/.395 OBP/.500 SA. Bats-L BAL-2R 3b-4e25, LF/CF/RF-4(+2)e16 INJ Risk-15, LH--2b- 6.4 3b-2.5 HR-1.7 BB-4 .380/.409/.540 OPS-.948, RH--2b- 8 3b-3.3 HR-2 BB-4 .475/.500/.674 OPS-1.174
11.1971 Joe Grzenda, LHRP, Senators, 5-2 1.92 1.009 3R Career best ERA, WHIP, H9, BB9, SO9, SO/BB ratio. Grzenda was a journeyman lefty specialist and fringe major leaguer, who at the age of 34 put together one magical season. Expansion Senators/Rangers could use a good lefty relief pitcher. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/734732/1670/1/70
12. 2014 Sean Doolitle LRP OAK 0.73 WHIP 89 K's in 63 IP. Would give Oakland a stud lefty to team with righty Eckersley (could opt for the even more dominant 2018 card, but he only had 45 IP that year) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91672/2014/1/2014
13. 1956 Red Wilson DET C .289 AVG .393 OBP .452 SLG 278 PA. Threw out 55.4%, 10% higher than the league average. Would give Postwar Tigers an upgrade at C.
14. 2006 Joel Zumaya. RP Detroit Tigers. 83 IPs with 97 K's, 233 ERA+, 10,5 K per 9ip, 0.6 HR/9, an RP only who can pitch 2/3 innings
15. 1969 Mack Jones MON LF Bats-L Career-high .270 BA, .379 OBP, .488 SLG, 867 OPS, 22 HR & 79 RBI. Darling of the first-year Montreal Expo fans, the left-field bleachers in Jarry Park were nicknamed "Jonesville." He hit the very first HR in a Major League regular season game in Canada and was a major part of making baseball in Montreal a success. 10-year veteran currently has no ATG card, and deserves one badly.
16. 1984 Alejandro Pena, RHSP, Dodgers 12-6 2.48 1.164 Led N.L. in ERA and ShO. Career bests in GS, W, IP, ShO, HR9, K and BB/9. Pena blew out his arm the following year, but reinvented himself as a pretty good relief pitcher.
17. 2012 Brandon Moss OAK 1b-3e27/ rf-3(-1)e9/ lf-3e9 Slashline: 291/.358/.596 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1385/2012/1/2012
18. 2011 Starlin Castro - CHC - SS - Slashline: .307/.341/.432 - League leader in hits with 207 and was an All-Star in his age 21 season (2011). 12 total seasons in the MLB with 1,722 career hits. Key player in the Cubs 'rebuild years' of the 2010s and would add to the Cubs ATG SS options.
19. 1948 Gene Bearden. CLE. LH S/R. Key member of the Tribe’s last championship. Knuckle curve that induced 42 GIDP. 20-7, 2.43 ERA. 229 IP. Completed 15 of his 29 starts. 6 shutouts. Only 9HR allowed. WW2 vet who served honorablty during the war. Played on several service clubs. Made the bigs at age 27. Beat the Red Sox in a 1-game playoff to get his team into the series. Pitched a shutout in Game 3, then saved the clincher. This season was his only shining moment, but it still gleams today.
20. 2011 Mike Adams, TEX, RH R1/C0, 3L. Helps TEX bullpen. No BP singles either way.
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/90666/2011/1/2011
21. 1989 Mike Bielecki Cubs SP* 18-7 3.14 CYA-9 his best season i think 14 years no card i could find https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/30869/1690/1/90
22. 1883 Tony Mullane, St. Louis, SP, throws both (but mostly righty) 35-15, 2.19 0.968. Career bests in W%, WHIP, H9, HR9, & BB9. Near career bests in W & ERA. Won 30+ games 5 straight seasons. Mullane’s 284 career wins are 4th most among pitchers NOT in the HOF (behind Roger Clemens at 354, Bobby Mathews at 297 and Tommy John at 288). Having no card adds insult to injury.
23. 2004 Carlos Lee, CWS, Bats-R, E Balance, LF-4(+1)e0, .305/.366/.525, 31 HR, 99 RBI, 2099 Games-No Card, CWS-exp is VERY light at LF
24.1925 Ben Paschal Yankees. 1028 OPS Right handed 2L Left/Center/Right 3 on Max. Pinch hitter and 4th Outfielder to the great Yankee teams.
25. 1994 Bob Hamelin, DH/1B, Kansas City ROY - Left Handed one year wonder, slashed .282/.388/.599, 25 doubles, 1 triple, 24 homers in just 375 plate appearances https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3211/1690/1/90
26. 1987 Randy Ready, 3B/2B/LF, SD Padres, RHH, 2L, .309/.423/.520. Infielder with a pretty sick card, clutch neutral, price probably moderated by shaky glove. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/839926/1680/1/80
27. 1964 Jim Pagliaroni, C, PIT, RHH, E, .295/.383/.454. Average defense and arm, given a 1 INJ rating in Superstar '60s set (unusual for a catcher) https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/39219/1660/1/60
28. 1930 Smead Jolly ' The Arkansas Assassin' bats left .313 Batting average with193 hits 38 doubles 12 triples 16 home runs and 116 RBI's 'Smead wasn't much of a guy with the glove but he was murder with the wood.'
29. 2016 Masahiro Tanaka, SP, NY Yankees, RHP. 14-4 in 199 IP. 165 Ks. 3.07 ERA vs league averge 4.20. Excellent 140 ERA+. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/500013/2016/1/2016
30. 2004 Brandon inge Det ---We can always use Catchers / Utility players https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/551/1700/1/120
31.2023 Felix Bautista, Baltimore Orioles, RP, 8-2, 1>48 ERA, 33 Saves, AS, 11th in Cy Young voting. O's team can use more good closers. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/100045/2023/1/2023
32. 2021 Brandon Woodruff, MIL, RHP, Brewers need more SPs! 2.56 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, 211 K
33. 2004 Oliver Perez 2.98 ERA 1.15 WHIP. 196 IP, 239 SO. Lefty, 1L. [20-year career, needs a card]
34. 2021 Kyle Schwarber, BOS, His best offensive card, 32 HR, .266/.374/.554, .928 OPS
35.