- Posts: 89
- Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2023 10:20 am
Please note a slight usage adjustment for 2025.
Minimums:
275 PA Hitters
100 IP Starters (S or S/R)
45 IP Relievers
25.3 parameters are as follows.
1. One nomination per member only
2. When we hit 38 unique nominations we will begin voting
3. We will have one poll of 50 cards; the top 25 will be added
4. Next "x" highest vote getters will get another shot in 25.4
Please submit nominations in a 'Year Player Team Position Comments' format.
To be included in the 25.3 poll:
2016 Madison Bumgarner SF SP 19
2023 Garret Cole NYY SP 19
2010 Brian Wilson SFG RP 19
2010 Carlos Marmol Cubs RP 18
1894 Mike Griffin BRO OF 18
2008 Geovany Soto CHC C 18
1971 Joe Grzenda Senators RP 18
2014 Pat Neshek St.Louis RP 17
1983 John Denny PHI SP 17
2005 Carlos Delgado Marlins 1B 16
1880 George Gore CF CHC 16
1913 Jake Daubert 1B 16
1. 1998 Brad Ausmus Houston C 1(-2)e3 7*/-(17-6) Bal- E .713 ops 18 year career, 10 with the Astros. NO CARD. Would be Houston's best defensive catcher. Definitely deserves a card.
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3860/1690/1/90
2. 1942 Ted Williams Boston LF 3(0)e4 Bal-1R Triple Crown season .356/36/137 (pacoboy)
3. 2000 Alex Rodriguez Seattle SS 10.4 war highest of his career .316/.420/.606 41 hr 134 rbi https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/990/1700/1/120
4. 2023 Freddie Freeman LAD 1B Bulletproof season with an astounding 59 doubles to go with 29 HR and 23/24 stolen bases and a 331/410/567 slash line. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91399/2023/1/2023
5. 1980 Miguel Dilone CLE OF .341 BA 61 SB NO CARD for this 12 year MLB Vet
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/33051/1980/4/1980
6. 1956 Ed Bailey CIN C. This is his best year at 936 OPS, absolutely crushed right hand pitching. Tied for 2nd best NL OPS with minimum 440 plate appearances.
7. 1966 Sam McDowell LSP Cleve - 2.87 ERA, 6 H/9, 10.4 K/9. 3 hit chances L, 4 hit chances R. Great 5 day starter addition
8. 1974 Jim Wynn LA Dodgers CF / WAR - 6.9, AVE - 271, OB 393, SLG 497, OPS - 890, HR - 32, RBI - 108, BB - 108
9. 1960 Jim Bunning RSP Detroit 252IP 2.79 ERA 1.15 WHIP 64 BB 20 HR Allowed. LED AL in K's 201, Ratio 3.14, K/9IP 7.2, and Pitcher WAR 6.6. All this despite having a 11-14 W/L record in 34 GS & 36 GP. Spent 9 years with the Tigers, and 6 with Phil(2 of which were hanger ons). Would be nice to have a Bunning card for the Tigers and an overall improvement to Detroit Pitching!
10. 2022 Andres Gimenez CLE 2B (1e12)/SS (2e18) bats-L (2L) .297/.371/.466, 17 hr, 20 sb, 141 ops+, 7.4 bWAR, led league in hbp (25), 6th in MVP voting, gold glove, no card https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/95006/2022/1/2022
11. 1931 Frankie Frisch. The first BBWAA NL MVP. A better cardinals card than his existing 34
12. 2021 Colin McHugh great Middle Relief RPO. R2, -5 Hold, 5L so effective against LHB's, low balk/WP's. 0 errors and best of all No HR chances on his card. shouldn't be too expensive to fill the Middle/tied and late role.
13. 1968 Gaylord Perry SF Giants RHSP-9* (16 W, 2.45 ERA, 1.029 WHIP, only 10 HR in 291 IP). Perry’s first 10 years were spent with the Giants, but his only Giants’ card is his unusable rookie season. He needs a better card from his years with the Giants, and in 1968 he had his best ERA and WHIP with San Fran. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/39443/1660/1/60
14. 1994 Rafael Palmeiro L 4L 926 OPS 1b3e6 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/2729/1690/1/90
15. 2000 Gabe White Colorado RP 84 IP. .94 WHIP. 11 years no card.
16. 1972 Wilbur Wood, White Sox, LHSP 24-17 2.51 1.059. Led AL in games started, W & IP, 2nd in shutouts & pitcher WAR. Career highs in games started, IP, W & shutouts. 2nd career bests as SP in WAR, ERA, WHIP, H9, BB9. Cy Young runner up. Started more games (49) and had more IP (376.2) than ANY pitcher in the 105 years of the modern baseball era (post 1919). With 49 starts, in 1972 SOM changed its rules to allow Wood just 2 days rest between starts!
17. 1962 Ernie Banks - First year at 1B, every card of Ernie is at SS (or 3B), he spent half his career at 1B and should have a 1B card. 37 HR's and .809 OPS (his highest after making the move to first).
18. 1909 Three Finger Brown CHC SP
19. 1930 Babe Ruth NYY 49 hrs 136 bbs .349 BA .493 OBP
20.1958 Sandy Koufax BKN/LA 11-11 WL mortal ERA (any year where he could relieve would be cool)
21. 2013 Jayson Werth WAS .318 BA .398 OBP .532 SLG, 25 HR (most as a Nat). Only 1 ATG card and he is with PHI. No cards with WAS. Arguably he was the key signing that led to the Nats success last decade. Vs LHP 1.092 OPS with a respectable .884 OPS vs RHP
22.
23.
24.
25.
Minimums:
275 PA Hitters
100 IP Starters (S or S/R)
45 IP Relievers
25.3 parameters are as follows.
1. One nomination per member only
2. When we hit 38 unique nominations we will begin voting
3. We will have one poll of 50 cards; the top 25 will be added
4. Next "x" highest vote getters will get another shot in 25.4
Please submit nominations in a 'Year Player Team Position Comments' format.
To be included in the 25.3 poll:
2016 Madison Bumgarner SF SP 19
2023 Garret Cole NYY SP 19
2010 Brian Wilson SFG RP 19
2010 Carlos Marmol Cubs RP 18
1894 Mike Griffin BRO OF 18
2008 Geovany Soto CHC C 18
1971 Joe Grzenda Senators RP 18
2014 Pat Neshek St.Louis RP 17
1983 John Denny PHI SP 17
2005 Carlos Delgado Marlins 1B 16
1880 George Gore CF CHC 16
1913 Jake Daubert 1B 16
1. 1998 Brad Ausmus Houston C 1(-2)e3 7*/-(17-6) Bal- E .713 ops 18 year career, 10 with the Astros. NO CARD. Would be Houston's best defensive catcher. Definitely deserves a card.
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3860/1690/1/90
2. 1942 Ted Williams Boston LF 3(0)e4 Bal-1R Triple Crown season .356/36/137 (pacoboy)
3. 2000 Alex Rodriguez Seattle SS 10.4 war highest of his career .316/.420/.606 41 hr 134 rbi https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/990/1700/1/120
4. 2023 Freddie Freeman LAD 1B Bulletproof season with an astounding 59 doubles to go with 29 HR and 23/24 stolen bases and a 331/410/567 slash line. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91399/2023/1/2023
5. 1980 Miguel Dilone CLE OF .341 BA 61 SB NO CARD for this 12 year MLB Vet
https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/33051/1980/4/1980
6. 1956 Ed Bailey CIN C. This is his best year at 936 OPS, absolutely crushed right hand pitching. Tied for 2nd best NL OPS with minimum 440 plate appearances.
7. 1966 Sam McDowell LSP Cleve - 2.87 ERA, 6 H/9, 10.4 K/9. 3 hit chances L, 4 hit chances R. Great 5 day starter addition
8. 1974 Jim Wynn LA Dodgers CF / WAR - 6.9, AVE - 271, OB 393, SLG 497, OPS - 890, HR - 32, RBI - 108, BB - 108
9. 1960 Jim Bunning RSP Detroit 252IP 2.79 ERA 1.15 WHIP 64 BB 20 HR Allowed. LED AL in K's 201, Ratio 3.14, K/9IP 7.2, and Pitcher WAR 6.6. All this despite having a 11-14 W/L record in 34 GS & 36 GP. Spent 9 years with the Tigers, and 6 with Phil(2 of which were hanger ons). Would be nice to have a Bunning card for the Tigers and an overall improvement to Detroit Pitching!
10. 2022 Andres Gimenez CLE 2B (1e12)/SS (2e18) bats-L (2L) .297/.371/.466, 17 hr, 20 sb, 141 ops+, 7.4 bWAR, led league in hbp (25), 6th in MVP voting, gold glove, no card https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/95006/2022/1/2022
11. 1931 Frankie Frisch. The first BBWAA NL MVP. A better cardinals card than his existing 34
12. 2021 Colin McHugh great Middle Relief RPO. R2, -5 Hold, 5L so effective against LHB's, low balk/WP's. 0 errors and best of all No HR chances on his card. shouldn't be too expensive to fill the Middle/tied and late role.
13. 1968 Gaylord Perry SF Giants RHSP-9* (16 W, 2.45 ERA, 1.029 WHIP, only 10 HR in 291 IP). Perry’s first 10 years were spent with the Giants, but his only Giants’ card is his unusable rookie season. He needs a better card from his years with the Giants, and in 1968 he had his best ERA and WHIP with San Fran. https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/39443/1660/1/60
14. 1994 Rafael Palmeiro L 4L 926 OPS 1b3e6 https://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/2729/1690/1/90
15. 2000 Gabe White Colorado RP 84 IP. .94 WHIP. 11 years no card.
16. 1972 Wilbur Wood, White Sox, LHSP 24-17 2.51 1.059. Led AL in games started, W & IP, 2nd in shutouts & pitcher WAR. Career highs in games started, IP, W & shutouts. 2nd career bests as SP in WAR, ERA, WHIP, H9, BB9. Cy Young runner up. Started more games (49) and had more IP (376.2) than ANY pitcher in the 105 years of the modern baseball era (post 1919). With 49 starts, in 1972 SOM changed its rules to allow Wood just 2 days rest between starts!
17. 1962 Ernie Banks - First year at 1B, every card of Ernie is at SS (or 3B), he spent half his career at 1B and should have a 1B card. 37 HR's and .809 OPS (his highest after making the move to first).
18. 1909 Three Finger Brown CHC SP
19. 1930 Babe Ruth NYY 49 hrs 136 bbs .349 BA .493 OBP
20.1958 Sandy Koufax BKN/LA 11-11 WL mortal ERA (any year where he could relieve would be cool)
21. 2013 Jayson Werth WAS .318 BA .398 OBP .532 SLG, 25 HR (most as a Nat). Only 1 ATG card and he is with PHI. No cards with WAS. Arguably he was the key signing that led to the Nats success last decade. Vs LHP 1.092 OPS with a respectable .884 OPS vs RHP
22.
23.
24.
25.