- Posts: 1975
- Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm
This is the Stud player poll for 17.3, please pick 4 players you'd like to see added to ATG. Top 5 will go.
Parameters: Batters greater than or near 1.000 OPS, Pitchers sub 1.00 whip.
While I still feel there are many Zero carded players to add I heard the interest in some of the missing historic seasons. So we vote.
Voting will close 3PM PT Tuesday, Sept 5th.
Here's the key...
Last Name / First Name / Year / Franchise / Position / Current Cards in ATG / years in career / Qualifications
VOTE!
Added card links where possible, feel free to add links if you have them!
The card links with a /60 /70 /80 or /90 at the end are from Mystery Games. Mouse over the desired year to see the appropriate card.
KEY:
MVP-X = where they ended up that season in the MVP voting
CY-X = CY voting
ROY-X = Rookie of the year voting
INJ+ = 15g injury risk
MBC = Much Better Card than currently in set
BC = Better Card than currently in set
SS = Silver Slugger
GG = Gold Glove
Seymour Cy 1905 CIN OF 1 16 MBC 377/429/559/988 21tp
Pelty Barney 1906 SLB SP* 1 10 BC 0.951whip 16-11 25cg 260in
Zimmerman Heine 1912 CHC 3B 1B 1 13 MBC 372/418/571/989 MVP-6 INJ+
Kauff Benny 1914 IND OF 0 8 370/447/534/981
Sisler George 1922 SLB 1B 2 15 420/467/594/1061 1e18 MVP-1
Heilmann Harry 1923 DET RF 1B 2 17 403/481/632/1113 MVP-3 INJ+
Rice Harry 1925 HOU OF 0 9 359/450/568/1028 MVP-5 INJ+
Manush Heine 1928 SLB LF 1 17 BC 378/414/575/989 MVP-2
Watkins George 1930 STL RF 1B 2 7 MBC 373/415/621/1037 INJ+ New Franch
Mize Johnny 1947 NYG 1B 2 15 302/384/614/998/51hr/MVP-3/would be first Giants card
Mantle Mickey 1957 NYY CF 3 18 365/512/665/1177/MVP-1
Sanders Reggie 1995 CIN RF CF 0 17 975 MVP-6 INJ+
Lankford Ray 1997 STL CF 0 14 996OPS MVP-16 INJ+
Vaughn Greg 1998 SD LF 1 15 MBC 272/363/597/960 MVP-4 SS 50HR New Franch
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3060/1690/1/90
Alou Moises 2000 HOU LF RF 1 17 355/416/623/1039 INJ+, New Franch
Hidalgo Richard 2000 HOU OF 0 9 314/391/636/1028 MVP-20
Sosa Sammy 2001 CHC RF 3 18 328/437/737/1174 MVP-2 INJ-0 3L
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3430/1690/1/90
Sweeney Mike 2002 KC 1B 0 16 340/417/563/979 MVP-20 INJ+
Bonds Barry 2004 SF LF 3 22 362/609/812/1422 MVP-1 SS 4+2e5
Drew J.D. 2004 BRV RF CF 0 14 305/436/569/1006 MVP-6
Saito Takashi 2007 DOD RP 0 7 0.715whip 39sv
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/90508/2007/1/2007
Kemp Matt 2011 DOD CF 0 12 324/399/586/986 MVP-2 GG 1-2e5 AA (19-14)17
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/597/2011/1/3011
Cano Robinson 2012 NYY 2B 1 13 313/379/550/929 MVP-4 GG SS 1e6 INJ-0 8R
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/182/2012/1/2012
Davis Chris 2013 BAL 1B 0 10 286/370/634/1004 MVP-3, SS 6R 2e6
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1340/2013/1/3013
Jansen Kenley 2016 DOD RP 0 8 0.67whip 4R 47sv R1/C6
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91501/2016/1/3016
Parameters: Batters greater than or near 1.000 OPS, Pitchers sub 1.00 whip.
While I still feel there are many Zero carded players to add I heard the interest in some of the missing historic seasons. So we vote.
Voting will close 3PM PT Tuesday, Sept 5th.
Here's the key...
Last Name / First Name / Year / Franchise / Position / Current Cards in ATG / years in career / Qualifications
VOTE!
Added card links where possible, feel free to add links if you have them!
The card links with a /60 /70 /80 or /90 at the end are from Mystery Games. Mouse over the desired year to see the appropriate card.
KEY:
MVP-X = where they ended up that season in the MVP voting
CY-X = CY voting
ROY-X = Rookie of the year voting
INJ+ = 15g injury risk
MBC = Much Better Card than currently in set
BC = Better Card than currently in set
SS = Silver Slugger
GG = Gold Glove
Seymour Cy 1905 CIN OF 1 16 MBC 377/429/559/988 21tp
Pelty Barney 1906 SLB SP* 1 10 BC 0.951whip 16-11 25cg 260in
Zimmerman Heine 1912 CHC 3B 1B 1 13 MBC 372/418/571/989 MVP-6 INJ+
Kauff Benny 1914 IND OF 0 8 370/447/534/981
Sisler George 1922 SLB 1B 2 15 420/467/594/1061 1e18 MVP-1
Heilmann Harry 1923 DET RF 1B 2 17 403/481/632/1113 MVP-3 INJ+
Rice Harry 1925 HOU OF 0 9 359/450/568/1028 MVP-5 INJ+
Manush Heine 1928 SLB LF 1 17 BC 378/414/575/989 MVP-2
Watkins George 1930 STL RF 1B 2 7 MBC 373/415/621/1037 INJ+ New Franch
Mize Johnny 1947 NYG 1B 2 15 302/384/614/998/51hr/MVP-3/would be first Giants card
Mantle Mickey 1957 NYY CF 3 18 365/512/665/1177/MVP-1
Sanders Reggie 1995 CIN RF CF 0 17 975 MVP-6 INJ+
Lankford Ray 1997 STL CF 0 14 996OPS MVP-16 INJ+
Vaughn Greg 1998 SD LF 1 15 MBC 272/363/597/960 MVP-4 SS 50HR New Franch
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3060/1690/1/90
Alou Moises 2000 HOU LF RF 1 17 355/416/623/1039 INJ+, New Franch
Hidalgo Richard 2000 HOU OF 0 9 314/391/636/1028 MVP-20
Sosa Sammy 2001 CHC RF 3 18 328/437/737/1174 MVP-2 INJ-0 3L
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3430/1690/1/90
Sweeney Mike 2002 KC 1B 0 16 340/417/563/979 MVP-20 INJ+
Bonds Barry 2004 SF LF 3 22 362/609/812/1422 MVP-1 SS 4+2e5
Drew J.D. 2004 BRV RF CF 0 14 305/436/569/1006 MVP-6
Saito Takashi 2007 DOD RP 0 7 0.715whip 39sv
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/90508/2007/1/2007
Kemp Matt 2011 DOD CF 0 12 324/399/586/986 MVP-2 GG 1-2e5 AA (19-14)17
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/597/2011/1/3011
Cano Robinson 2012 NYY 2B 1 13 313/379/550/929 MVP-4 GG SS 1e6 INJ-0 8R
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/182/2012/1/2012
Davis Chris 2013 BAL 1B 0 10 286/370/634/1004 MVP-3, SS 6R 2e6
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/1340/2013/1/3013
Jansen Kenley 2016 DOD RP 0 8 0.67whip 4R 47sv R1/C6
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/91501/2016/1/3016