Strat-O-Matic Baseball 365

1978 Dave Concepcion - the man played SS forever for Reds; can we not have at least one card that isn't an INJ risk?

1965 Leo Cardenas

2004 Adam Dunn

1902 Noodles Hahn - better card, Reds db SP weak

1995 Reggie Sanders - no card in ATG

1988 Danny Jackson

1986 Rob Murphy

1954 Ted Kluszewski

Klu also on larger streamlined list from Bill's list

Haven't looked over the pitchers yet but hitters...
Joey Votto - 2010, no card in ATG
Cy Seymour - 1905, this year quite a bit better than his 1 in ATG
Adam Dunn - 2004, no card
Reggie Sanders - 1995, no card

Klu's 54 is better but he has 3 cards already, one of which isn't that far behind '54.

Pitchers

Agree with Hahn '02
Ted Abernathy '67 should be considered, his best year .978 whip
I like Rob Murphy too but would rank Abernathy ahead of him

All in all for me Votto '10 would be my Reds poster child for a nomination followed by...
Hahn 1902
Dunn 2004
Seymour 1905
Abernathy 1967

Looked at Hahn a little closer, his 1904 yr looks like it could result in a better card. Anyone have an opinion on 1904 vs 1902?

Votto is fine, I just prefer, in most instances, to fill poorly represented players or players with no card before recent cards. I know I'm probably in the minority on that, but I guess that's why they call it an opinion.

2003 Jose Guillen

Rosie2167 wrote:Looked at Hahn a little closer, his 1904 yr looks like it could result in a better card. Anyone have an opinion on 1904 vs 1902?

The only thing I see better is a lower WHIP in 1904. His adjusted ERA is much better in 1902

You guys are taking ALL my thunder. I want to nominate a Red but you all have taken them.