- Posts: 299
- Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2021 9:41 pm
Sat Oct 02, 2021 3:48 pm
I saw someone else do something similar so if this is frowned upon I apologize in advance. I do know there’s a voting system to nominate and then add
in the all time great set a lot of the players only have one option here are some from 2000 to now that I think should have a second. I avoided players still active except a few who are close to retirement.
My list was longer but I shortened it. I’m going to list a player the year I’d suggest and a note or two on the year. The end is just a run off of my list
1) Scott Rolen 1998 (I know I said 2000+ but his best year we don’t have ) .290/.391/.532 31 home runs
2) Joey Votto 2012 .337/.474 /.567
3) Dustin Pedroia 2011 his only 20+hr season and gold glove
4) Jose Reyes 2006 .300 64sb 17 triples
5) Yadier Molina 2013 .319/.359/.477
6) Ryan Braun 2012 .319/.391/.595 41home runs
7) Jacoby Ellsubury 2009 .301 70sb
8) Bobby Abreu 2004 .301/.428/.545 30 home runs
9) Chris Carpenter 2009 17-4 2.24 /1.00
10) Brad Lidge 2008 1.95era 41 saves
11) David Wright 2008 .302/.390/.534
12) Luis Castillo 2000 .334 62sb
13) Carlos Delgado 2003 .302/.426/.593
14) Adrian Gonzalez 2011 .338 /.410 Gold glove
15) Jorge Posada 2003 .281/.405/.518
16)Matt Holliday 2010 .312/.390/.532
17) Johnny Damon 2004 .304/.380/.477
18) Andrew Jones 2006 41 home runs gold glove
19) Magglio Ordonez 2002 .320/.381/.597
20) Prince Fielder / Ryan Howard 2007 both
21) Joe Nathan / Armando Benitez / Jonathan Papelbon
22) Tim Lincecum/ Madison Bumgarner / Cole Hamels / Bartolo Colon
23) Jason Giambi / Adam Dunn / Troy Glaus / Nelson Cruz
24) Jim Edmonds / Carlos Gonzalez/ Matt Kemp
25) Matt Carpenter / Brandon Phillips / Armias Ramirez / Eric Chavez
Of course there’s more feel free to add to the list
in the all time great set a lot of the players only have one option here are some from 2000 to now that I think should have a second. I avoided players still active except a few who are close to retirement.
My list was longer but I shortened it. I’m going to list a player the year I’d suggest and a note or two on the year. The end is just a run off of my list
1) Scott Rolen 1998 (I know I said 2000+ but his best year we don’t have ) .290/.391/.532 31 home runs
2) Joey Votto 2012 .337/.474 /.567
3) Dustin Pedroia 2011 his only 20+hr season and gold glove
4) Jose Reyes 2006 .300 64sb 17 triples
5) Yadier Molina 2013 .319/.359/.477
6) Ryan Braun 2012 .319/.391/.595 41home runs
7) Jacoby Ellsubury 2009 .301 70sb
8) Bobby Abreu 2004 .301/.428/.545 30 home runs
9) Chris Carpenter 2009 17-4 2.24 /1.00
10) Brad Lidge 2008 1.95era 41 saves
11) David Wright 2008 .302/.390/.534
12) Luis Castillo 2000 .334 62sb
13) Carlos Delgado 2003 .302/.426/.593
14) Adrian Gonzalez 2011 .338 /.410 Gold glove
15) Jorge Posada 2003 .281/.405/.518
16)Matt Holliday 2010 .312/.390/.532
17) Johnny Damon 2004 .304/.380/.477
18) Andrew Jones 2006 41 home runs gold glove
19) Magglio Ordonez 2002 .320/.381/.597
20) Prince Fielder / Ryan Howard 2007 both
21) Joe Nathan / Armando Benitez / Jonathan Papelbon
22) Tim Lincecum/ Madison Bumgarner / Cole Hamels / Bartolo Colon
23) Jason Giambi / Adam Dunn / Troy Glaus / Nelson Cruz
24) Jim Edmonds / Carlos Gonzalez/ Matt Kemp
25) Matt Carpenter / Brandon Phillips / Armias Ramirez / Eric Chavez
Of course there’s more feel free to add to the list