The Rarest Bird...S(5*)

Carlos Quintana has an S(5*) rating in the 2015 set!

I don't see any S(5*) ratings in any of the online 20xx sets, curious if he is the first?

I've seen all the cards since the online game started and I do not recall ever seeing one.

Did a quick query against my ATG database. There are none there.

Carlos Quintana has an S(5*) rating in the 2015 set!

I don't see any S(5*) ratings in any of the online 20xx sets, curious if he is the first?

An I out of the loop ? How do you know what Carlos Quintana's rating is?

Carlos Quintana has an S(5*) rating in the 2015 set!

I don't see any S(5*) ratings in any of the online 20xx sets, curious if he is the first?

An I out of the loop ? How do you know what Carlos Quintana's rating is?

it is in the rating guide SOM sells.

Why would Quintana get an S5* rather than S6* for 32 starts and 206.1 IP?

What did McHugh get for 32 GS and 203.2 IP?

It is a little inconsistent I would say.

Mchugh is S(6*)

This just doesn't sound right. Seems like he should be an S6

It may be a typo
mlb.com game log
shows 4 starts of 5 or 4 IP

13 starts of 6 IP
11 starts of 7 IP

1 8 IP game

and 2 9 IP

probably is a 6 or a 7 and I'd say 7 as the low inning games were in April....may have been weather related etc.

It may be a typo.....

I asked and received this reply:

Yes, the S5* is the correct rating for Quintana.

No explanation though.