Strat-O-Matic Baseball 365

Alright guys,

Let's have some fun with the pricing. Who do you guys think are too high and who do you think are too low?????

Did they make a mistake with Ohtani's hitting card? It seems like his OB chances vs. RHP in particular should be much higher.

I see the problem, their graph is way off. I wonder how many other cards or graphs have mistakes.

Radagast Brown wrote:Did they make a mistake with Ohtani's hitting card? It seems like his OB chances vs. RHP in particular should be much higher.

I see the problem, their graph is way off. I wonder how many other cards or graphs have mistakes.

Looks like you figured out they put his pitcher's card there?

I think Michael Brantley is priced too high, especially considering how many similar players are priced lower...

It is a little off topic but I am disappointed again that Jason Kipnis has been dropped to a 4 at 2B.

I think JD-Mart is a bargain since he has been rated 4(-1). I would have rated him 5(+2). I'll buy

I was comparing M. Chapman's and Jose Ramirez' offensive stats and couldn't see why Ramirez cost $2.03M more than Chapman. As it turns out the little things add up.

Hits/OB/TB
Chapman - vs. LHP - 28/41/41 2 BPHR's
vs. RHP - 23/34/48 7 BPHR's

Ramirez - vs. LHP - 23/33/44 3 BPHR's
vs. RHP - 15/41/41 8 BPHR's

Chapman is the better offensive player by a bit. Then I started looking at other parts of their cards and can now see why there is a price difference.

Ramirez is a switch hitter. Stole 34 bases vs. 1 for Chapman. 10 fewer errors at 3rd. He's a 680 guys vs. Chapman's 600+.
Clutch is -2 vs. -5. 0 DP's vs. Chapman's 17. Ramirez has 2nd base eligibility. Not that you would play him there.

Subtract Chapman's advantage at the plate from Ramirez' intangibles and whaddya get? $2.03M

zzkev6 wrote:I think JD-Mart is a bargain since he has been rated 4(-1). I would have rated him 5(+2). I'll buy

I'll second that. Jumped right out at me on the first page

STEVE F wrote:

zzkev6 wrote:I think JD-Mart is a bargain since he has been rated 4(-1). I would have rated him 5(+2). I'll buy

I'll second that. Jumped right out at me on the first page

I'm not someone who knows much about this, but I frown on normal Homerun chances (2-10 roll) becoming BP HR chances.

Trout, including HBP has over 600 plate appearances yet has a 2 inj rating. Always thought the standard for a 1 inj rating was 600 PA's. I know a few years ago Bonds also had a 2 inj rating, but was still only subject to a 3 game max injury.

From what I understand HBP and Intentional Walks don't count as PA's in Strat. As a 2 injury I cant explain that