Totally respect Leeroy, but they're not "functionally identical." I think the new cards for Ruth, Mays, Giambi, Mize, Clemente are substantively different, to varying degrees.
The Ruth card is his 1919 Red Sox card, better fielder, great arm, runs well -- and a 15 game injury risk, unlike the others. Take a chance.
The Mays card (my nomination!) is a much different Mays card than the others -- higher BA, best season for steals, fewer homers, good triples. Kinda a small ballpark three or cleanup hitter.
Giambi's new card has a lot of doubles on it, unlike his existing card.
Mize's card has a lot of BA, doubles and triples, fewer homers than existing cards.
Clemente was my favorite player growing up, so I'll never offer anything but positivity about him!
Frankly, I'd love to see all players' seasons included in SOM, that's really what should be the goal -- a Utopian yearning, perhaps unrealistic
-- but it would make any questions like this moot. But it's always good to raise concerns and let conversations flow, thanks Leeroy!