Your RH batters will play 105 games in BPHR = 1 Your LH batters will play 111 games in BPHR = 1 + 12 games in BPHR = 3 (123 games total; 3/4 of your season)
You have 3 guys with the max 8 BPHR vs both LH & RH. That's a lot of outs.
Think about 1. replacing Pudge (and his 8 wasted BPHR) with a 3.5-4.1M guy of nearly equal defense w/fewer BPHR & higher OBA (Lollar, Sundberg, Schalk?) & upgrade your backup C to an .90M-1.00M guy (Grote? Dempsey?) 2. downgrading Works or Smith to a .65M-.90M LH specialist (just so you have one LH in the pen) 3. That would leave you 2.5M to 3.4M to boost your SP... and you'd still have thunderous offense.