Page 1 of 3

Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2014 5:54 pm
by danielz
2 3 W.Wells 4-10 Error On Foul Popup - C catch-x F9
0 W.Wells 4-10 1 Base Error - C b-1 catch-x F9
0 12 M.Mantle 4-10 Error On Foul Popup - C catch-x F9

Catcher is Campanella
All happened within 2 innings

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2014 10:14 pm
by rburgh
I participated in a game where, using dice, the 1e4 Cal Ripken card made 3 errors in the same game. Shit happens. There are probably over 5000 games played on this site every night, with the average game consuming 80+ dice rolls. So there rates to be a one in a million event about 3 times a week.

You should feel privileged to be a participant in one of them on occasion.

In other words:

Grow up!

The world has no obligation to operate within a framework where nothing bad ever happens to you.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2014 11:09 pm
by danielz
rburgh wrote:Grow up!


HUH?
All I was doing was pointing out an anomaly.
Perhaps you should lighten up.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2014 12:57 pm
by PATRICKCASSIDY
i wanna speak to agree w/ Danielz... he wasn't whining.


the board(s - if you include other games, have plenty of comments about similar occurrences). I didn't read his original as whining, maybe a bit of complaining, the same as you would if you were at a real game where something similar happened.


I still think Rick Monday is the best Cub cf in my lifetime (no disrespect of Dernier intended) and I once saw him lose one in the sun and almost get beaned.


realism at its best.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2014 1:10 pm
by bontomn
To rburgh: Don't know what prompted your comments to danielz, but I thought they were out of place. Others besides me are interested in hearing about anomalies like his.

By the way, it has been your turn to draft in the Franchise 1.0 League for some time.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2014 6:46 pm
by Badjam
Grow up?!

Between that l. clown that constantly berates people and this one, things seem to be heading in the wrong direction lately. Why are people so angry?

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2014 6:51 pm
by bkeat23
Badjam wrote:Grow up?!

Between that l. clown that constantly berates people and this one, things seem to be heading in the wrong direction lately. Why are people so angry?

Would you like to debate angry?

If we were both angry at the rest of the league would it be collusion?

Would that be funny?
Seinfeld funny or Carlin funny?

Don't you understand what I'm saying, should I parse out the thread into 10 different quotes so only I can follow it and it becomes meaningless to other humans?

:D

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 30, 2014 7:00 pm
by Valen
The world has no obligation to operate within a framework where nothing bad ever happens to you.

Yes it is. Pretty sure it is in the constitution somewhere.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sun Aug 31, 2014 12:28 pm
by rburgh
I have posted some of these points in various places. Let me put them all in one post.

1. The fact that bizarre things happen from time to time (Hack Wilson goes 7 or 7 with 4 HR, Campy makes 3 miscues in a single game, Somebody with a lefty team in Penmar rolls 22 of 31 times on the 5-day Pedro card, one of your one injury rolls guys gets hurt 6 times in a season while two others go scot-free.) is clear evidence that the dice rolls are, in fact, random. If they were attempting to make sure that all the possible rolls came up in the proper ratio over a short sample, this stuff wouldn't happen. Please note that one of the tag lines on the Indians' broadcasts is something like, "you never know what you might see when you come to a game."

2. There are a lot of games played every night on this site. So weird things are going to happen from time to time, and because of the sheer number of games played something extremely odd is going to happen several times a week. But the vast majority of games don't see these things.

3. There are some things that the game company does not divulge. Among them are the mechanism for bunting for base hits, what happens when a pitcher ceases to be an F9 for a particular game, how it decides to use relief pitchers within the parameters of the pitcher roles we assign, how it decides whether to pinch hit, etc. We just have to deal with it. I am in a PBM league where we use the current game, and the computer manager available in the current game is vastly better than this one, but also vastly more time-consuming to program. If that CM was available here, I would consider it quite a burden to start more than one team a week. And it would completely baffle new users. So they continue to use the relatively simplistic version, to make the game more user-friendly. I think that's a good thing, we need more managers here, not less, even at the expense of a poor computer AI.

Finally, when I see someone start a new topic with the title "Who Ya Kidding?", I automatically consider that to be whining without regard to the tenor of the post within. Nobody is kidding. Random number generators sometimes cluster similar or identical results in a very small sample size. If it were otherwise, then the random number generator would not be random. I regard the failure to accept this mathematical fact uncomplainingly as extremely infantile. And I would love to play poker regularly with those of you who can't accept it - I could quit my day job.

Re: Who Ya Kidding?

PostPosted: Sun Aug 31, 2014 1:24 pm
by motherscratcher
So, nobody is allowed to complain about a bad beat now?

OK, then.