Page 1 of 2
1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 12:36 pmby STEVE F
There is just NO WAY this is programmed as a *3-7/- (20-16).
60 SB's through 99 games, with stealing at aggressive and Cobb set at steal more. Should have 100 by now
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 1:01 pmby paul8210
STEVE F wrote:There is just NO WAY this is programmed as a *3-7/- (20-16).
60 SB's through 99 games, with stealing at aggressive and Cobb set at steal more. Should have 100 by now
Regardless of the ability of the catchers and pitchers? Cobb's 1915 stolen base count was 96, so, sounds like he's right on track.
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 1:11 pmby STEVE F
paul8210 wrote:STEVE F wrote:There is just NO WAY this is programmed as a *3-7/- (20-16).
60 SB's through 99 games, with stealing at aggressive and Cobb set at steal more. Should have 100 by now
Regardless of the ability of the catchers and pitchers? Cobb's 1915 stolen base count was 96, so, sounds like he's right on track.
Well, the other Cobb with the 20-16 stole 137 for me, and doesn't get on base near as much
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 3:30 pmby scorehouse
i thought u were joking!
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 3:34 pmby STEVE F
No, I truly believe the steal rating is not programmed correctly
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 4:04 pmby scorehouse
you even expect better results regardless of Hold and Catcher Hold ratings? what do consider an acceptable steal success %?
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 4:09 pmby STEVE F
Normally I like 75%. But in this case my main goal was to have Cobb set my personal SB record. Seemed like a slam dunk to beat the 1909 card for that record
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sat Jun 06, 2020 4:14 pmby scorehouse
what is that record number? the Milan card always seems to steal like crazy albeit he doesn't have near the OBP as Cobb's cards.curious how you end up. by the way what is Cobbs OBP at this point and what park?
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2020 9:12 amby scorehouse
how do you judge the stealing ability on Cobb's 1911 card?
Re: 1915 Cobb card flawed
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2020 1:26 pmby STEVE F
scorehouse wrote:how do you judge the stealing ability on Cobb's 1911 card?
Fair to poor. *17 is only good against fair to bad hold combos.
The *20 is AT WORST a 1-13 with a good lead, and with a bad lead of 1-16 can even steal quite a bit on second number , including steals of 3B