bid mcphee...

is it only me... has anyone ever had any success with bid mcphee... he's got to be my #1 major disappointment... every time i use him he proves to be a major flop... even against lefties... i'm done trying him...

No, it isn't only you. That OBP is tempting, and his defense is good.

But he always tanked for me as well

He was good enough for me the one time I used him, at $80M in a park that didn't help his numbers:

https://365.strat-o-matic.com/team/1388022

270/350/358 with 29 errors...

i question his fielding.....think he played defense without a glove.....like we did in high school softball

270/350/358 with 29 errors...

He's a 1e30, what exactly are you hoping for?

I never base card expectations on real-life stats -- only on value for the price. I considered that fair value for the price, cap and ballpark.