Page 1 of 2

Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Mon Oct 02, 2023 3:37 pm
by scorehouse
Bullpen Role has been modified.... what does all this mean? what is the Super Hal Role anyway?

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Mon Oct 02, 2023 3:58 pm
by bkeat23
It means they changed a parameter that is a mystery in the first place.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Mon Oct 02, 2023 7:14 pm
by STEVE F
All it means is that if you select the role of "middle man", that will now mean from the 3rd inning through the 6th, instead of the 1st through the 6th.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Tue Oct 03, 2023 7:49 am
by roniwas
Has anyone had the experience of letting HAL manage the bullpen? Aside from using a 9L and 9R, short innings (1-2), I let HAL make the decisions. My pens are usually 4 or 5, low $ relievers. In a small ball team this seems to work very well. This advice was given to me by egvrich. I'm only now trying it out in a different type of strategy. Comments?

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Tue Oct 03, 2023 9:03 am
by scorehouse
so r u saying if an RP is is set on Mid Man but checked for 7th inning or later, HAL won't use him?

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Tue Oct 03, 2023 10:28 am
by DonSutton
roniwas wrote:Has anyone had the experience of letting HAL manage the bullpen? Aside from using a 9L and 9R, short innings (1-2), I let HAL make the decisions. My pens are usually 4 or 5, low $ relievers. In a small ball team this seems to work very well. This advice was given to me by egvrich. I'm only now trying it out in a different type of strategy. Comments?

This is how I do it, on advice I saw posted by egvrich. I like the results better than trying to micro manage the settings.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Tue Oct 03, 2023 3:39 pm
by MARKSERRI
This is how I do it, on advice I saw posted by egvrich. I like the results better than trying to micro manage the settings.

I've taken to doing the same thing.
I will change it up if I find a particular reliever is not getting enough innings.
I also assign specialist roles and a mop up man .That's usually it.
Hal does better with choices.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Wed Oct 04, 2023 8:19 am
by egvrich
At the time of my "retirement", I had played around with what I believe to be an even better, albeit a bit more expensive strategy in NON-DH Leagues ...

(2) Decent $2-$2.5M Relievers (Gossage & Howe being a good example) - No settings at all
(1) 9L Set to Quick Hook avoid RH
(1) 9R Set to Quick Hook avoid LH

With this setup the 9L & 9R seemed to get used more wisely and have much better slash lines and giving HAL two solid options outside of that seems to be sufficient.

The Decent relievers will get 80% of the innings and the specialists will face mostly the correct sided hitters.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Wed Oct 04, 2023 10:46 am
by goffchile
I find the the "less is more" strategy with regards to bullpen roles to pretty effective. just like in the movie, the more orders you give hal, the more likely it is he kills the crew.

Don't worry about "saves" as a stat--largely useless.

If he as some reasonable choices, he is more likely (but not guaranteed) to make the reasonable choice.

Re: Middle Man Super Hal

PostPosted: Wed Oct 04, 2023 8:56 pm
by bkeat23
Last night's series, 2 different teams, I had a specialist stay in to give up 7 and 12 runs in a single inning.
One team has Arroyo and Liska set as middle/set/closer.
The other has no settings on Arroyo and Liska.