Mon May 27, 2024 2:26 pm
Im remembering my take from previous research or experience
I believe this is why they were all earned....
it doesnt matter what runners moved up, or anything on that play (the error)
it matters (if I remember correctly) that even if that play would have resulted in an out (like a strikeout) with no runners advancing or scoring, the next two plays were both hits, which would have scored the runs anyway
I believe that's the criteria, that the runs would have been earned either way, even with an out, so in this case the error didn't create more runs (except the batter who reached on an error) and that batter (Petway) never scored (thrown out at home on final play of inning).....so, his getting on base was result of error, but the important factor here is that "no runs scored as a result of an error" (more than they would have with no error)
that's how I recall it, I could be wrong, expert opinion it's definitely not, just what i remember from a long time ago