- Posts: 529
- Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 2:09 pm
While we are waiting for AdamKatz to make his picks, how about the question of the Cy Young award for the 70's. That is much harder than the MVP.
Matlack (3.03 ERA) has the best numbers but he only played in 2 of his 4 eligible seasons. Vida Blue (3.27 ERA) had the next best numbers but his numbers would have been worse if he had stayed around for season #3. After that, there is Seaver, Gaylord Perry (the most wins), Koosman (the best ERA at 3.44 among pitchers who were in all 4 seasons full-time), and maybe a few more. Even looking at the guys who were only eligible for three years, nobody jumps out as great in all 3 years. If I had to pick someone, I would go with Blue.