3b defense

I have had Phil Garner who is rated 2e27 at 3b. But he managed to get 8 errors in the first 18 games. 18 put outs; 39 assists with a .877 percentage. Should I write this off as a fluke (as limited sample size?) Could the card be wrong? I panicked and put Buford at 3b 4e 23 and Garner at dh. No errors from Buford in 9 games. Should I put Garner back?

Yes, absolutely put Garner back.

Playing Buford instead of Garner is silly. Sure Garner has had extremely bad luck, but his rating is still much better than Buford's. That hasn't changed.

Thanks, your posts on this board are invaluable.