New24 TKL - Old Thread - Do Not Use

I vote yes

Rules change proposal regarding division alignments:

1st Season Alignment- Based on previous 2 seasons (1 card year) record. So for the 2012 cards the division alignments will be based on a team's record for the two 2011 seasons.

2nd Season Alignment- Random, using randomizer.org.

This proposal would eliminate any incentive to lose in the 1st season to get into a weak division in the 2nd season. For the 1st season "tanking" would be somewhat reduced by using both seasons' and the relatively large year to year changes in teams' fortunes. Of course we could always just go with random alignment for both seasons.

Vote Yes/No

Votes so far, needs 16 to pass:

Yes[b]
Travelingjack
Ed
Spider
GeoffB
Rburgh
JamesZ

[b]No
Thechamp
Aray
Apollo
Fredpaii

I am going to go with No, for right now. Maybe we can think of something better before Season 1 next year

I will vote no, wait till next year, as the Cubs would say.

I will vote no, wait till next year, as the Cubs would say.

We'll be waiting forever then!

Hey, I've been waiting almost my whole life for a winning Pirates season! (I thought for sure that wait would be over this year...)

I vote yes.

i vote yes

I vote yes

vote "no"