bullpen: Fingers and Quisenberry

Just wondering if anybody has had any luck using the $4.5 million Fingers and Quisenberry. Fingers' card looks like it might be pretty good; I'm more skeptical about Quisenberry (looks too vulnerable against LH). Just wondering if they're worth the expense -- or if you could do just as well with a 3 mil guy. Thanks for any numbers!

We're doing some franchise leagues where Fingers is the best option for the Brewers franchise and the Padres franchise.

Fingers has been used 4 times:
2 uses of the 4.74 R2 one
2 uses of the 3.58 R3 one

Once the 4.74 card had really good rate stats (3.03 ERA, 1.03 WHIP)
Once the 4.74 card was slightly out-performed by the 3.58 card in rate stats (@ 3.80 ERA, 1.25-1.30 WHIP)

Based on that, I'd say, "It depends."

I think, based on usage and your starting staff, that the 3.58 Fingers could produce as your closer and spend that extra $1m somewhere else.