49. ehlekev - Dave McNally 1968
50. rjnewman - Jim Fregosi 1969 (proxy)
51. gfdwarf07 - Ruben Amaro 1964
52. katzenjammer - Barney Schultz 1964
53. krazykat - Jim Maloney 1963
54. doug_tucker10 Bill Mazeroski 1966
55. risden - Larry Dierker 1969
56. kenhutchings - Denny McLain 1969
57. GordieHowe - Billy Williams 1964
58. allstarinc - Tommie Agee 1969
59. LMBombers - Ron Hunt 1969
60. Rick Smith - Boog Powell - 1966
61. Rick Smith - Don Buford - 1965
62. LMBombers - Jim Bunning 1966
63. allstarinc - Tim McCarver 1967
64. GordieHowe - Eddie Fisher 1966
65. kenhutchings - Johnny Callison 1964
66. risden
67. doug_tucker10
68. krazykat
69. katzenjammer
70. gfdwarf07
71. rjnewman
72. ehlekev
As a word of explanation, it was not my intent to create a controversy when I made my pick of McLain. Although it wasn't specifically mentioned, I had figured that a player was yours once automatically selected, and when picking the '69 McLain, I wanted to explain why I was not selecting his best year, so that people wouldn't be questioning my sanity (which they do anyway, so why go to all that trouble).
They're coming to take me away, hah, hah...