With the 3 cards all having something to be said for using with just 110 mil to spend the 62 Mays represents more than 10% of your payroll. So I would go with one of the 2 cheaper cards. From there it just depends on makeup of your league and whether you expect to see more RH or LH pitchers. Without that context I would probably go with the 54 card because it is 1R and in general you face a 2-1 to 3-1 ratio of RH-LH pitching in most leagues. And it has slightly better fielding.