Pre-Card Draft Keeper League -- Season 28

I need some clarification on what we are voting on. Is this vote on a rule change to the constitution or to allow the trade to go through? I voted yes because there is nothing in our current constitution which would disallow the trade. I'm in favor of adding language like the fowldawg corollary but shouldn't that be a separate vote?

I vote no, but would like to see the rules language change if there is support for this time of deal.

I need some clarification on what we are voting on. Is this vote on a rule change to the constitution or to allow the trade to go through? I voted yes because there is nothing in our current constitution which would disallow the trade. I'm in favor of adding language like the fowldawg corollary but shouldn't that be a separate vote?

The vote is for this particular deal, since it was not considered when the rules were drafted.

I would support adding a new rule for future deals, which clarifies this question.

Thanks. I was considering changing my vote to no just to get the draft going again but changing the constitution without a vote would set a bad precedent so I'll stick with yes.

When I began this poll on Thursday, I said "This is not a major issue for me, so if a majority of the remaining managers (other than Dan and I) say the deal should not be allowed, then we will cancel it."

Since a majority equals half plus one, that means 10/2 = 5 and 5 + 1 = 6; thus, 6 negative votes will kill the deal.

So far, we have 4 negative votes with 2 managers not voting yet...

* * * * *

If a manager has no room for another prospect, can he trade away a prospect pick before his turn rolls around?

1. josephkendall - No
2. thisisdan26 - Yes, posted that trade
3. mrbbworld-
4. Palmtana - Yes
5. mfl536 - yes
6. tcochran - Yes, confirmed that trade
7. bbasebrawl - Yes
8. willmurr24 -
9. terry101- No- see explanation
10. nythawk -no( because u cant do it in spring or supp drafts either)
11. ironwill1 - no
12. blsmith7 - yes

Before I vote ,please clarify .Can a manager drop a prospect during a draft.If not when can he drop players and when can't he?

Before I vote ,please clarify .Can a manager drop a prospect during a draft.If not when can he drop players and when can't he?

Neither players nor prospects can be dropped, after a draft has begun

I love spit like this .it's half the reason I play online games. In my small mind the question becomes does the draft pick exist or not .If it exists,absent any specific rules ,it must be under someones control.If a prospect could be dropped during a draft bringing a prospect roster under ten,the draft pick would be activated and could be used by said player to choose a player or trade the pick,and so it exists. If the player with ten prospects can not drop a player to access the pick it does not exist .And so before I confuse myself further I vote no.

When I began this poll on Thursday, I said "This is not a major issue for me, so if a majority of the remaining managers (other than Dan and I) say the deal should not be allowed, then we will cancel it."

Since a majority equals half plus one, that means 10/2 = 5 and 5 + 1 = 6; thus, 6 negative votes will kill the deal.

So far, we have 5 negative votes with 1 manager not voting yet...

* * * * *

If a manager has no room for another prospect, can he trade away a prospect pick before his turn rolls around?

1. josephkendall - No
2. thisisdan26 - Yes, posted that trade
3. mrbbworld-
4. Palmtana - Yes
5. mfl536 - yes
6. tcochran - Yes, confirmed that trade
7. bbasebrawl - Yes
8. willmurr24 - no
9. terry101- No- see explanation
10. nythawk -no( because u cant do it in spring or supp drafts either)
11. ironwill1 - no
12. blsmith7 - yes

Where can I find all the league rules?