Ok, comments on Stoney's comments:
Big M - Agree with Stoney, Very good top end of the rotation, spent $40 mil on pitching. Very weak O v RHP. Strong arm in the OF only in Rf. Lack of O v RHP would concern me. Also *very* injury prone.
DJ- Also agree about pitching spent almost $45 mil!
Almost all in the SPs. Like Big M, will struggle v RHP. Very good v LHP. also agree that he has the most HRs in the division. Also you're right about his OB, especially v RHP.
Semper - *Only* spent $36 mil on pitching. Agreed, offensively challenged v LHP for a change. OK v RHP. Has a lot of players.
Stoney - $35 mil on pitching. By far the best O in the division. Yeah, has three injury guys and not much depth to back them up.
Thoughts:
Stoney - will go as far as his O will take him. Pitching isn't great, but isn't *that* bad. I think he will shape up well in his division.
DJ - Will do well v LHP and struggle v RHP. Strong SPs will keep him in most games. Playing a 3 at 2b doesn't help the D, but it's OK overall with a 1 at SS. Lack of O v RHP is problematic in the long run, especially v the Central Division.
Big - almost the same as DJ, but without as much power and not as good v LHP.
Semper - Second best O v RHP in the division. But so weak v LHP that would be a concern. Decent otherwise.
Personally I like Stoney's team the best, but there is so much pitching on DJ andBig's teams that they might be better than they look on paper. Semper will end up making a ton of moves so who knows what he'll look like in 20 games!
Gotta go. More on the other divisions as time allows.