I really like your comment! I laughed out loud, but with some agreement.
There's the analytical part of how we play this game - and then there's the psychological/emotional part of what we do! Sometimes it's a favourite player who performs well for us (perhaps overachieving from luck). Sometimes it's a player/card that just looks too good to pass up. I know I have my card favourites each year, and you see certain players being selected by other managers on multiple teams.
Anyway, I can relate to your love/hate relationship in strat with Matt Kemp/2012! Made me laugh!
