Live drafts - I have a confession to make

Here is a list of ADP for the 16 live drafts I participated in for the ATG 6 card set. There are new players that are relevant to uncapped live drafts now, but you should be able to slot most of them in somewhere reasonable.

Note that Maddux went anywhere from 1st to 16th, and Pedro 5th to 27th. There were other "wild cards" - Walker 6th to 39th, Jeter 8th to 46th. I think the comment above pertained mainly to the drafts populated solely by the "regulars."

Name P Team Used ADP Hi Lo
Ruth, Babe LF NYY1921 16 2.25 1 5
Bonds, Barry LF SF2001 16 2.56 1 4
Mantle, Mickey CF NYY1956 16 3.69 1 7
Gibson, Josh C NeL 16 4.06 1 7
Hornsby, Rogers 2B STL1922 16 4.44 1 6
Speaker, Tris CF BOS1912 16 8.19 5 12
Foxx, Jimmie 1B PHA1932 16 8.94 5 11
Charleston, Oscar CF NeL 16 9.13 5 12
Maddux, Greg P ATL1995 16 10.63 1 16
Mays, Willie CF SF '62 16 10.94 5 19
Williams, Ted LF BOS1941 16 13.81 5 19
Martinez, Pedro P MON1997 16 14.75 5 27
Dimaggio, Joe CF NYY1941 16 15.25 8 23
Alexander, Pete P PHN '15 16 15.50 8 21
Cobb, Ty CF DET1911 16 17.38 12 23
Brett, George 3B KC '80 16 17.88 12 24
Aaron, Hank RF MIL1959 16 19.88 12 28
Gehrig, Lou 1B NYY '27 16 19.88 11 32
Wagner, Honus SS PIT1908 16 20.69 14 29
Bagwell, Jeff 1B HOU1994 16 23.06 8 43
Walsh, Ed P CHW1910 16 23.19 13 31
Walker, Larry RF COL1997 16 23.50 6 39
Musial, Stan CF STL1948 16 25.38 16 34
McGwire, Mark 1B STL1998 16 27.88 18 41
Thomas, Frank 1B CHW1994 16 28.88 21 44
Brown, Three Finger P CHC1908 16 28.88 17 37
Rodriguez, Alex SS TEX2003 16 29.56 9 43
Jeter, Derek SS NYY '99 16 31.06 8 46
Kiner, Ralph LF PIT1949 16 31.06 18 39
Collins, Eddie 2B PHA1914 16 32.81 16 41
Joss, Addie P CLE1908 16 34.81 24 44
Johnson, Walter P WAS1910 16 35.06 26 46
Morgan, Joe 2B CIN '75 16 35.50 24 47
Pujols, Albert 1B STL '08 16 37.75 16 50
Beckwith, John 3B NeL 16 37.81 25 53
Stearnes, Turkey CF NeL 16 38.81 24 47
Mauer, Joe C MIN '09 16 39.19 25 48
Mathewson, Christy P NYG1905 16 42.63 30 52
Yount, Robin SS MLA '82 16 42.69 22 51
Griffey Jr., Ken CF SEA1993 16 43.44 17 57
Snider, Duke CF BKN '53 16 44.13 27 56
Koufax, Sandy P LA '65 16 44.13 18 60
Wells, Willie SS NeL 16 46.44 23 67
Adams, Babe P PIT '09 16 50.06 39 65
Piazza, Mike C LA1997 16 51.06 35 69
Jones, Chipper 3B ATL '99 16 52.00 38 70
Carlton, Steve P PHI1972 16 53.25 32 77
Clemens, Roger P TOR1997 16 55.69 25 76
Gibson, Bob P STL1968 16 56.88 41 71
Boudreau, Lou SS CLE1948 16 56.94 38 64
Sisler, George 1B STB '20 16 57.69 28 89
Simmons, Al LF PHA '29 16 58.94 35 95
Lajoie, Nap 2B CLE1904 16 59.56 36 78
Pfiester, Jack P CHC '06 16 61.31 40 84
Wilson, Hack CF CHC1930 16 62.69 20 71
Johnson, Randy P ARI '99 16 62.88 38 82
Helton, Todd 1B COL2000 16 63.50 35 83
Bender, Chief P PHA1910 16 64.88 42 85
Drysdale, Don P LA1964 16 65.13 49 78
Gehringer, Charlie 2B DET1934 16 65.44 46 77
Jackson, Reggie RF OAK1969 16 65.88 38 89
Boggs, Wade 3B BOS1987 16 67.81 47 81
Banks, Ernie SS CHC '59 16 67.94 29 84
Schmidt, Mike 3B PHI1980 16 68.56 45 87
Ripken Jr., Cal SS BAL1991 16 71.00 51 84
Biggio, Craig 2B HOU1997 16 71.88 40 85
Alomar, Roberto 2B CLE '99 16 73.25 55 88
Hartnett, Gabby C CHC1930 16 73.38 42 107
Coveleski, Stan P CLE1917 16 73.38 49 87
Maris, Roger RF NYY '61 16 76.75 49 99
Mathews, Eddie 3B MIL1959 16 78.44 42 102
Paige, Satchel P NeL 16 79.38 57 93
Robinson, Frank RF BAL '66 16 79.88 44 99
Cedeno, Cesar CF HOU '72 16 81.13 36 155
Cicotte, Eddie P CHA '19 16 81.75 62 92
Santana, Johan P MIN2004 16 84.44 37 128
Jones, Slim P NeL 16 89.13 61 122
Sandberg, Ryne 2B CHC1990 16 89.25 53 124
Wagner, Billy P HOU '99 16 89.31 59 114
Camnitz, Howie P PIT '09 16 89.75 66 104
Vance, Dazzy P BKN '24 16 89.94 56 117
Rivera, Mariano P NYY1996 16 90.06 49 115
Hamilton, Billy CF BSB1896 2 91.00 53 129
Hubbell, Carl P NYG1933 16 93.75 59 126
Eckersley, Dennis P OAK '90 16 93.81 53 116
Waner, Paul RF PIT '27 16 93.88 55 125
Cash, Norm 1B DET1961 16 95.81 66 114
Guidry, Ron P NYY '78 16 97.81 75 111
Hoffman, Trevor P SD1998 16 98.38 53 113
Young, Cy P BOS1901 16 98.63 62 106
Sutter, Bruce P CHC '77 16 98.81 71 120
Campanella, Roy C BKN '53 16 99.25 50 126
Edmonds, Jim CF STL2004 16 99.44 50 165
Gooden, Dwight P NYM1985 16 101.88 68 139
Henderson, Rickey LF OAK '90 16 102.94 65 140
Stargell, Willie LF PIT '71 16 103.75 55 137
Ott, Mel RF NYG1929 16 104.19 74 134
Yastrzemski, Carl LF BOS '67 16 105.94 65 140
Lincecum, Tim P SF '09 16 106.06 64 134
Guerrero, Vladimir RF MON2002 16 106.63 60 189
Chesbro, Jack P NYY1904 16 110.75 92 125
Greenberg, Hank 1B DET1938 16 111.44 61 129
Cochrane, Mickey C PHA1931 16 112.25 65 142
Smith, Chino RF NeL 16 112.44 59 151
Clark, Jack 1B STL '87 16 113.19 78 147
Reulbach, Ed P CHC '06 16 113.56 75 139
Percival, Troy P ANA1995 16 115.31 83 134
Allen, Dick 1B CHA '72 16 117.88 91 130
Heilmann, Harry RF DET1925 16 118.25 84 146
Wilson, Jud 1B NeL 16 119.56 74 152
Trammell, Alan SS DET1987 16 120.00 77 155
Grove, Lefty P PHA1931 16 120.63 89 137
Hershiser, Orel P LA '85 16 120.69 62 139
Waddell, Rube P PHA1905 16 123.31 103 149
Smoltz, John P ATL2003 16 124.94 88 149
McLain, Denny P DET '68 16 126.88 70 173
Suttles, Mule 1B NeL 16 127.38 80 158
Wilhelm, Hoyt P CHW1965 16 127.94 80 147
Schultz, Barney P STL '64 16 128.31 95 157
Hernandez, Willie P DET '84 16 129.31 86 164
Ramirez, Manny RF CLE2000 16 129.50 93 154
Nen, Robb P SF2000 16 129.69 54 158
Frisch, Frankie 3B NYG '21 16 130.06 79 158
Jackson, Joe LF CHW1920 16 132.50 83 167
Rodriguez, Ivan C TEX '99 16 133.19 85 169
Torriente, Cristobal CF NeL 16 133.31 99 154
Brown, Willard CF NeL 16 133.38 97 165
McGinnity, Joe P NYG1904 16 133.81 82 162
Smith, Lee P CHC1983 16 137.81 103 155
Tudor, John P STL1985 16 138.88 57 191
Franco, John P CIN1988 16 140.81 103 164
Delahanty, Ed LF PHI1901 16 141.19 95 173
Keefe, Tim P NYG1889 16 142.81 112 173
Wright, David 3B NYM '07 16 143.63 79 196
Marichal, Juan P SF1965 16 145.63 90 178
Alfonzo, Edgardo 3B NYM1998 2 150.00 147 153
Torre, Joe 3B STL1971 16 150.63 87 224
Berra, Yogi C NYY1956 16 151.06 107 206
Dibble, Rob P CIN1989 16 151.88 126 169
Mize, Johnny 1B STL1940 16 153.63 101 195
Wetteland, John P TEX1997 16 154.69 118 163
Gomez, Lefty P NYY1934 16 155.00 112 169
Lloyd, Pop SS NeL 16 155.19 107 179
Scott, Mike P HOU '86 16 155.31 104 223
Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA2004 16 155.81 102 192
Giles, Brian CF PIT2002 16 158.25 97 226
Hall, Tom P MIN1970 16 158.31 118 198
Mackey, Biz C NeL 16 159.75 111 176
Williams, Matt 3B SF1994 16 160.75 60 238
Fidrych, Mark P DET1976 16 160.75 89 224
Appling, Luke SS CHW1936 16 161.00 76 234
Radatz, Dick P BOS1964 16 161.00 115 186
Carew, Rod 1B MIN '77 16 162.00 61 210
Hodges, Gil 1B BKN1957 16 164.31 127 183
Miljus, Johnny P PIT '27 16 164.31 135 182
O'Neill, Paul RF NYY1994 16 165.31 86 221
Russo, Marius P NYY '39 16 165.38 110 197
Fryman, Woodie P MON '80 16 167.06 115 186
Cooper, Mort P STL1942 16 167.06 124 195
Higuera, Teddy P MIL1988 16 168.69 106 221
Ortiz, David 1B BOS '07 16 169.25 121 189
Richard, J.R. P HOU '79 16 171.69 133 183
Killebrew, Harmon 1B MIN1961 16 172.25 115 210
Blanchard, Johnny C NYY '61 16 172.63 112 214
Howard, Elston C NYY '61 16 174.31 104 196
Bench, Johnny C CIN1972 16 174.63 119 231
Mossi, Don P DET1960 16 175.69 144 194
Wright, Wild Bill RF NeL 16 177.19 141 195
Henke, Tom P TOR '85 16 177.94 149 190
Foster, George LF CIN1977 16 178.19 111 233
Arroyo, Luis P NYY '61 16 181.06 132 196
Rizzuto, Phil SS NYY '50 16 181.69 80 222
Marshall, Mike P MON '72 16 185.19 149 197
Foster, Big Bill P NeL 2 185.50 90 281
Fisk, Carlton C BOS1977 16 191.94 115 226
Carter, Gary C MON '80 16 193.81 134 246
Drabowsky, Moe P BAL '66 1 194.00 194 194
Salmon, Tim RF ANA1995 16 194.44 105 266
Lazzeri, Tony 2B NYY1932 2 194.50 190 199
Clear, Mark P CAL '79 1 195.00 195 195
Perry, Gaylord P CLE '72 13 195.80 139 269
Belle, Albert LF CLE1995 16 196.63 109 229
Winfield, Dave RF SD '79 16 198.50 123 225
McGraw, John 3B STL1900 16 200.19 72 285
Phillippe, Deacon P PIT1900 15 200.80 150 264
Beltran, Carlos CF NYM '07 1 201.00 201 201
Plank, Eddie P PHA1909 16 201.56 126 264
Dickey, Bill C NYY '39 16 203.19 132 227
Johnson, Oscar Heavy LF NeL 16 204.31 135 263
Vaughan, Arky SS PIT1934 1 206.00 206 206
Sosa, Elias P LA '77 16 206.13 141 231
Johnson, Home Run SS NeL 16 207.31 157 243
Klein, Chuck RF PHI1930 16 207.69 131 251
Bailey, Ed C CIN1957 1 209.00 209 209
Traynor, Pie 3B PIT1929 1 210.00 210 210
Roenicke, Gary LF BAL '83 1 210.00 210 210
Seaver, Tom P NYM1971 13 210.31 158 280
Leonard, Buck 1B NeL 15 210.67 123 273
Smith, Ozzie SS STL '87 16 210.69 141 265
Schilling, Curt P ARI2002 15 210.73 108 258
Scales, Tubby 2B NeL 16 212.81 102 249
Collins, Ripper 1B STL '34 1 213.00 213 213
Gwynn, Tony RF SD1987 16 213.06 135 246
Myers, Randy P CIN1990 15 213.07 123 257
Puckett, Kirby CF MIN '88 16 215.50 157 276
Lee, Cliff P CLE '08 5 215.60 136 270
Monroe, Bill 3B NeL 16 215.94 168 263
Cooper, Cecil 1B MLA '82 1 218.00 218 218
Robinson, Brooks 3B BAL1964 15 218.80 136 281
Petrocelli, Rico SS BOS1969 16 218.81 110 288
Ennis, Del RF PHN '50 1 219.00 219 219
Cronin, Joe SS WAS1930 16 219.75 148 276
Lanier, Max P STL '46 16 220.19 172 268
Robinson, Neil CF NeL 16 221.19 169 271
Brandom, Chick P PIT '09 16 223.13 165 277
Hughes, Tom P BSB1916 16 223.31 163 260
Garcia, Mike P CLE '54 15 223.60 172 267
Slaughter, Enos RF STL1942 1 224.00 224 224
Palm, Spoony C NeL 16 224.44 158 277
Lemon, Bob P CLE1952 7 225.57 171 272
Hernandez, Ramon P PIT1974 1 226.00 226 226
Haller, Tom C SF '62 16 226.50 142 294
Larkin, Barry SS CIN1992 16 226.88 156 295
Miller, Stu P BAL '66 16 226.94 174 276
Ayers, Doc P WAS1917 1 227.00 227 227
Short, Chris P PHN '64 16 227.25 167 263
Kendall, Jason C PIT1998 16 227.31 174 283
Blue, Vida P OAK1971 6 228.00 122 267
Hiller, John P DET '68 3 228.00 199 272
Williams, Billy LF CHC '70 2 228.50 227 230
Donaldson, John P NeL 16 229.69 172 270
Feller, Bob P CLE1946 4 229.75 200 280
Sosa, Sammy RF CHC '99 14 229.93 91 285
Marquard, Rube P NYG1913 16 230.88 119 291
Kent, Jeff 2B SF2002 16 231.00 155 293
Summers, Ed P DET '09 1 231.00 231 231
Utley, Chase 2B PHI '07 5 232.20 197 258
Nichols, Kid P STL1904 11 232.36 150 292
Connor, Roger 1B NYG1889 9 232.56 151 294
Schiraldi, Calvin P BOS '86 15 233.27 151 270
Thome, Jim 1B CHW2006 16 233.75 134 294
Bunning, Jim P PHI1966 1 234.00 234 234
Munson, Thurman C NYY1970 2 234.50 188 281
Cepeda, Orlando 1B SF1961 16 235.38 123 285
Dean, Dizzy P STL '34 14 235.93 164 257
Mattingly, Don 1B NYY '86 9 236.00 182 289
Roebuck, Ed P PHN '64 1 236.00 236 236
Strawberry, Darryl RF NYM1987 16 237.13 105 285
Fox, Nellie 2B CHW1959 11 237.27 171 295
McClure, Bob P CAL1989 16 237.38 184 294
Meyers, Chief C NYG '11 15 238.67 175 298
Clemente, Roberto RF PIT '69 16 238.75 146 289
Wynn, Early P CLE1956 7 238.86 200 280
Kluszewski, Ted 1B CIN '55 2 239.00 238 240
Honeycutt, Rick P OAK '90 15 239.20 195 253
Terry, Bill 1B NYG1929 3 239.50 197 282
Evers, Johnny 2B CHC1908 14 240.00 133 293
Williams, Bernie CF NYY1998 4 240.00 212 288
Dandridge, Ray 3B NeL 15 240.53 193 258
McMahon, Don P MLN '57 13 240.54 187 281
Hafey, Chick LF STL1929 16 240.56 166 267
Redus, Frog LF NeL 8 241.00 185 297
Hunter, Catfish P OAK '72 7 241.29 128 292
Cuyler, Kiki RF CHC '29 16 241.69 164 291
Darwin, Danny P HOU '86 14 241.71 201 278
O'Dell, Billy P MIL1965 15 242.07 189 278
Rusie, Amos P NYG1897 14 242.57 193 272
Quisenberry, Dan P KC1984 3 244.00 212 278
Cabrera, Miguel 3B FLA2006 15 244.67 149 286
Clark, Will 1B SF1989 7 245.43 145 296
Berkman, Lance LF HOU2001 14 245.64 185 284
Cone, David P KC1994 16 246.00 203 284
Consuegra, Sandy P CHA '55 1 246.00 246 246
Lofton, Kenny CF CLE1994 16 247.44 170 292
Colavito, Rocky RF DET1961 14 247.64 170 299
Howard, Ryan 1B PHI2006 13 247.77 166 300
Newhouser, Hal P DET1944 16 247.94 170 300
Steinfeldt, Harry 3B CHC '06 1 248.00 248 248
Bishop, Max 2B PHA1926 4 248.50 212 285
Fingers, Rollie P OAK '73 15 248.67 179 279
Suggs, George P CIN1911 8 248.88 173 299
Alou, Felipe RF SF '62 1 249.00 249 249
Halladay, Roy P TOR2003 5 249.20 178 271
Williams, Smokey Joe P NeL 15 249.33 167 287
Bonds, Bobby RF SF '73 5 250.00 212 284
Huggins, Miller 2B STL1912 1 251.00 251 251
Narleski, Ray P CLE '54 9 251.00 184 285
Murphy, Dale CF ATL1984 13 251.85 195 300
Nettles, Graig 3B NYY '78 5 252.40 158 300
Medwick, Joe LF STL1935 2 253.00 221 285
Righetti, Dave P NYY '86 2 253.50 221 286
Sutton, Don P LA1975 9 254.67 217 295
Konstanty, Jim P PHN '50 12 255.75 204 291
Manning, Max P NeL 16 255.88 163 280
Chance, Dean P MIN1967 1 256.00 256 256
Valentine, Ellis RF MON '80 4 256.50 214 299
Gordon, Joe 2B NYY '39 14 256.79 134 299
Kaline, Al RF DET1956 8 257.25 177 291
Palmeiro, Rafael 1B TEX '99 10 257.30 191 284
Reardon, Jeff P MON1985 7 257.71 151 299
Guerrero, Pedro LF LA '85 13 257.92 170 296
Canseco, Jose RF OAK1988 16 257.94 200 287
Galarraga, Andres 1B MON1989 12 258.50 203 283
Matlock, Leroy P NeL 13 258.69 217 299
Rowe, Schoolboy P DET1934 1 259.00 259 259
McCovey, Willie 1B SF '70 14 259.36 171 293
Trouppe, Quincy C NeL 16 259.38 200 279
Ojeda, Bob P NYM '86 16 259.44 176 297
Doby, Larry CF CLE1950 7 260.00 179 300
Davis, Eric LF CIN '86 4 260.25 231 289
Lindstrom, Freddie 3B NYG1928 5 260.40 218 298
Perranoski, Ron P LA '65 3 260.67 254 268
Dixon, Rap RF NeL 9 261.00 229 298
Face, Roy P PIT1959 16 261.31 168 294
Gossage, Goose P NYY '78 15 261.73 185 292
Blyleven, Bert P MIN1973 1 262.00 262 262
Howard, Frank LF WAS '69 6 262.50 235 291
Robinson, Hank P STL1915 7 262.57 214 294
Peters, Gary P CHW1964 11 262.73 232 294
Decinces, Doug 3B CAL1982 3 263.00 243 293
Travis, Cecil SS WAS1941 15 263.20 175 299
Antonelli, Johnny P NYG1956 2 263.50 238 289
Taylor, Jack P CHC '06 1 264.00 264 264
Winters, Nip P NeL 15 264.07 178 295
Jones, Cleon LF NYM '69 13 264.23 205 297
Grich, Bobby 2B BAL1974 5 264.50 233 296
Nelson, Gene P OAK '90 10 264.60 195 278
Raines, Tim LF MON '86 5 264.80 208 292
Hess, Otto P CLE '06 15 264.87 191 296
Dihigo, Martin SS NeL 8 265.00 222 298
Chance, Frank 1B CHC '06 4 265.00 237 293
Dawson, Andre CF MON '80 12 265.50 194 289
Heath, Jeff LF CLE1941 1 267.00 267 267
Williams, Lefty P CHA '19 2 267.00 259 275
Doerr, Bobby 2B BOS '46 2 267.50 254 281
Wood, Joe P BOS1911 16 267.63 207 289
Averill, Earl CF CLE '34 5 267.80 245 300
Hickman, Jim 1B CHC '70 2 269.00 254 284
Freehan, Bill C DET '68 8 269.63 221 300
Pesky, Johnny SS BOS '46 4 270.00 248 282
Sanguillen, Manny C PIT '71 1 270.00 270 270
Merritt, Jim P MIN '65 10 270.40 219 297
O'Neill, Steve C CLE '20 8 270.50 252 292
Wheat, Zack LF BKN '24 10 270.60 209 293
Fielder, Prince 1B MIL '09 5 271.00 249 293
Rice, Jim LF BOS '78 1 271.00 271 271
Martinez, Edgar 3B SEA1992 1 272.00 272 272
Linzy, Frank P MIL1972 1 272.00 272 272
Rosen, Al 3B CLE1952 2 272.50 252 293
Furillo, Carl RF BKN '53 3 272.67 267 282
Youngs, Ross RF NYG1920 13 272.92 202 289
Grimes, Burleigh P PIT1928 1 273.00 273 273
Lombardi, Ernie C CIN '40 6 273.67 261 299
Burroughs, Jeff RF TEX1974 1 274.00 274 274
Nelson, Jeff P NYY1997 9 274.33 175 288
Pierce, Billy P CHA '55 12 274.75 166 294
Brosius, Scott 3B NYY1998 11 275.18 190 298
Robinson, Jackie 2B BKN1949 13 275.23 190 287
Wolfgang, Mellie P CHW1916 9 275.44 171 283
Parrish, Lance C DET1985 2 276.50 260 293
Chapman, Ray SS CLE '20 4 277.50 258 297
Knowles, Darold P WAS1967 9 277.67 247 296
Lyons, Ted P CHW1927 3 278.00 255 297
Bennett, Dennis P PHN '64 3 278.00 265 289
Wynn, Jimmy CF HOU '69 9 278.22 179 290
Trucks, Virgil P CHW1954 4 278.25 270 288
Fernandez, Tony SS TOR '86 3 278.67 255 299
Delancey, Bill C STL '34 2 279.00 270 288
Beggs, Joe P CIN '40 1 279.00 279 279
Day, Leon P NeL 1 279.00 279 279
Downing, Brian LF CAL1982 2 280.00 279 281
Orosco, Jesse P NYM1985 2 280.00 260 300
Harder, Mel P CLE '34 1 280.00 280 280
Worrell, Todd P STL '87 1 280.00 280 280
Rettenmund, Merv LF BAL1970 7 280.86 222 286
Henry, Bill P CHC '59 12 281.67 218 296
Moore, Wilcy P NYY '27 9 282.22 231 290
Lyons, Jimmie LF NeL 2 282.50 275 290
Spahn, Warren P BSB1947 1 283.00 283 283
Craig, Roger P STL '64 1 283.00 283 283
Faber, Red P CHW1921 8 283.88 208 287
Bell, Cool Papa CF NeL 7 284.00 270 298
Rose, Pete RF CIN '69 3 284.00 277 295
Bando, Sal 3B OAK '73 1 284.00 284 284
Wills, Maury SS LA1962 1 284.00 284 284
Pina, Horacio P OAK '73 1 284.00 284 284
Richert, Pete P BAL1970 1 284.00 284 284
Pennington, Superman 1B NeL 14 284.93 208 292
Smith, Reggie RF LA '77 3 285.00 284 286
Killian, Ed P DET '09 2 285.00 273 297
Pollet, Howie P STL '46 3 285.33 281 290
Evans, Dwight RF BOS1984 4 286.75 266 299
Santo, Ron 3B CHC1967 4 286.75 282 296
Garciaparra, Nomar SS BOS1997 1 287.00 287 287
Oswalt, Roy P HOU2001 9 287.67 129 292
White, Roy LF NYY1971 2 288.00 281 295
Avila, Bobby 2B CLE '54 1 288.00 288 288
Dykes, Jimmie SS PHA '29 1 288.00 288 288
Tekulve, Kent P PIT '79 12 288.58 245 292
Dietz, Dick C SF1971 1 289.00 289 289
Drabek, Doug P PIT1990 1 289.00 289 289
McGee, Willie CF STL1985 1 291.00 291 291
Baker, Frank 3B PHI1913 11 291.55 178 297
Rolfe, Red 3B NYY '39 1 292.00 292 292
Bedrosian, Steve P ATL '82 6 293.00 203 267
Page, Joe P NYY1949 1 293.00 293 293
Seminick, Andy C PHN '50 13 293.08 243 299
Lavelle, Gary P SF1984 3 293.67 292 295
Smith, Hilton P NeL 10 293.70 197 285
Whitaker, Lou 2B DET1983 10 293.80 238 300
Young, T.J. C NeL 3 294.00 289 299
Pena, Tony C PIT1984 2 294.00 293 295
Koosman, Jerry P NYM '69 8 294.00 212 295
Burgmeier, Tom P MIN1975 2 294.50 294 295
Kremer, Ray P PIT '27 1 295.00 295 295
Lundy, Dick SS NeL 2 295.50 295 296
Hill, Pete CF NeL 11 296.55 208 300
McDougald, Gil SS NYY1956 3 297.00 295 300
Stephenson, Riggs LF CHC '29 2 297.00 297 297
Tenace, Gene 1B OAK '73 1 297.00 297 297
John, Tommy P LA '77 1 297.00 297 297
Lucas, Red P CIN1927 1 297.00 297 297
Lefferts, Craig P SD '84 8 297.88 245 295
Brouthers, Dan 1B BSB1889 1 298.00 298 298
Bibby, Jim P PIT '79 1 298.00 298 298
Leifield, Lefty P PIT '09 1 298.00 298 298
Russell, Reb P CHW1915 1 298.00 298 298
Cooper, Walker C BSB1951 1 299.00 299 299
Beazley, Johnny P STL1942 1 299.00 299 299
Grim, Bob P NYY1956 1 299.00 299 299
Selkirk, George LF NYY '39 1 300.00 300 300
Noles, Dickie P CHC '84 1 300.00 300 300
Smith, Dave P HOU1989 1 300.00 300 300
McDowell, Roger P NYM '86 1 300.00 300 300
Goslin, Goose LF WAS1926 9 304.78 237 298
Garber, Gene P PHN '77 6 316.83 221 300
Lolich, Mickey P DET '68 4 317.75 197 291
Shea, Red P NYG '21 6 326.67 234 296
Ford, Whitey P NYY1958 4 336.75 239 286
Ellis, Sammy P CIN1964 5 343.20 266 299

Wow. Thank you rburgh! This may take me a while to digest, but it will certainly help when I do participate in a live draft league. I'm sure this is appreciated by lots of newbies at this like me.

rburgh, that is an interesting list. But what happened to the crazy Arky Vaughn and Eddie Mathews cards for ATG6? Arky was usually a pretty high pick back then. Obviously not relevant for ATG7 drafts, but I'm curious. The new Arky is still worth an early round pick, although not in the first five like in ATG6.

And ditto on your comments about live drafting and the need to adjust to how any one draft flows, even with a bunch of "regulars" in the league. It makes things much more interesting and fun, compared with the autodraft process.

Yes, this draft list is more relevant to how the cards were stacked back then.

Only lesser Duffy, Lajoie cards, to name a few. There were less CF options. so they went higher at that time.
When they were adding cards regularly, it was equal parts Pitcher and hitters, so that now the mid tier pitching pool has expanded so much that decent starters are easy to get often into round 12.

IMHO the draft lists help you know when its cool that you got a value. But team fit is more important. I have seen very successful teams that reach in every round, even one 100 win team, where every player on the roster was taken below their average draft position in every round through 8 or 10. Draft value isn't everything.

I agree draft position isn't everything- same for pro sports.

But isn't generally better when everyone doesn't work off the same lists?

I like DDope- but 90% of the time when a trade is proposed the logic goes back to what DDope says.

Same here- so and so is a round 5 player so I cant trade him for a round 7 player- EVEN if it does make for a better fit.