- Posts: 2945
- Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 7:25 pm
They are pretty close.
McCutchen is much better vs LHP, Trout better vs RHP, but not clearly as far ahead as McCutchen is in vs LHP.
I rate McC vs L 140, Trout a 91. vs RHP McC a 94, Trout a 117. Overall, McC a 116, Trout a 118.
Of course everyone here knows it's easier to get guys to kill LHP cheap, so we all prefer Trout. But if you can enough RHP killers else where, McC isn't bad.