- Posts: 585
- Joined: Mon Apr 08, 2013 10:00 pm
JoeyC wrote:pageian wrote:This may not be an ideal situation but if BCP7 isn't going to be here then dropping a new owner into his spot before anything baseball related has been decided seems like the lesser of all evils.
If it's no biggie, then let me take the 4th slot and put the new guy in my slot. Or, move everyone else up one slot and the new manager picks last. I just have a problem with allowing a new Manager the 4th pick (Mantle or Gibson or the likes) for four seasons while managers that were part of the original sign-up are left to pick later. If it appears that I'm being a squeaky wheel about this, then that's cool - just replace me as well and get two new managers.
JoeyC
I get what you're saying but penalizing a guy for replacing a no show by putting him last seems wrong, you're arbitrarily penalizing someone who stepped up and helped out but didn't meet some artificial deadline. Really, the only thing that changes is the name of the manager picking 4th, but your solution would penalize the guy helping out and reward the eight behind him. And why? Because the guy he replaced didn't show up to the draft. It's nobodies fault BCP7 didn't show up, certainly not the replacements, so why should anyone be penalized or rewarded? Once again the only thing that would change is the name of the manager picking 4th, I don't see how that's unfair to anyone.