6 Half Teams League - Draft

1) 3) mrharryc - Yankees Pre-War hitting
2) 11) reggie reigns - Giants EXP hitting
3) 7) krazykat - Cincinnati, Expansion Era Hitting
4) 1) NYMETS99- New York Yankees postwar hitting
5) 8) rburgh - Red Sox EXP Hitting
6) 6) Musial6 - Cardinals EXP Hitting
7) 5) Thomasmore - Cubs DB pitching
8) 9) bontomn - Cubs PRE hitting (proxy)
9) 12) sschu - Bos-db pitching
10) 4) treyomo - As PRE hitting
11) 2) JOEYC - St. Louis pre hitting
12) 10) FrankMansueto - Cleve EXP Hitting

Rd. 2
13. FrankMansueto - Oak EXP Hitting
14. JOEYC - CHW-db pitching
15. treyomo - NYG - DB pitching
16. ssch - HOU - exp hitting
17. bontomm - HOU - EXP pitching (proxy)
18. Thomasmore - Ny Giants pre hitting
19. Musial6 - TEX - EXP hitting
20. rburgh - Mon Exp Pitching
21. NYMETS99 - Det Pre Hitting
22. krazykat - Philadelphia A, Deadball Era Pitching
23. reggie reigns - Cleveland DB pitching
24. mrharryc - Atlanta EXP pitching

RD3

25. mrharryc - Milwaukee (Braves) hitting
26. reggie reigns - Brooklyn -Post hitting
27. krazykat - Oakland, Expansion Era Pitching
28. NYMETS99-post Brooklyn pitching
29. rburgh - CLE EXP Pitching
30. Musial6 - NYY - EXP - Pitching
31. Thomasmore - Orioles Post Hitting
32. bontomn - Twins EXP hitting (proxy)
33. sschu - KC-exp Hitting
34. treyomo - As DB hitting
35. JOEYC - Yankees Expansion Hitting
36. FrankMansueto - Pitt DB Pitching

Rd. 4
13. FrankMansueto - Wash DB Pitching
14. JOEYC - BOS pre hitting
15. treyomo - PHI DB hitting
16. ssch - LA-exp hitting
17. bontomm - CWS Exp -- Hitting
18. Thomasmore - CHC Exp Pitching
19. Musial6 - CLE - Post - Pitching (or LAD EXP pitching if Cleveland doesn't own Satchel Paige)
20. rburgh -
21. NYMETS99 -
22. krazykat -
23. reggie reigns -
24. mrharryc


Which means Satchel Paige is mine!!!! "So don't any of you homo (sapiens) be touching him!" Francis from Stripes.

His More expensive card is eligible in the fa draft

No way man - he's on the Cleveland Post Roster. I know it was never stated one way or the other but originally there was not to be any NELs or free agents, so he was locked in to the Cleveland Post roster at that time. In any franchise I've ever participated in that's always been the case.

rburgh, please don't make your pick until this is resolved, because if it's not the case, or the general consensus goes against this common practice, I want to make another choice!!!!

1) 3) mrharryc - Yankees Pre-War hitting
2) 11) reggie reigns - Giants EXP hitting
3) 7) krazykat - Cincinnati, Expansion Era Hitting
4) 1) NYMETS99- New York Yankees postwar hitting
5) 8) rburgh - Red Sox EXP Hitting
6) 6) Musial6 - Cardinals EXP Hitting
7) 5) Thomasmore - Cubs DB pitching
8) 9) bontomn - Cubs PRE hitting (proxy)
9) 12) sschu - Bos-db pitching
10) 4) treyomo - As PRE hitting
11) 2) JOEYC - St. Louis pre hitting
12) 10) FrankMansueto - Cleve EXP Hitting

Rd. 2
13. FrankMansueto - Oak EXP Hitting
14. JOEYC - CHW-db pitching
15. treyomo - NYG - DB pitching
16. ssch - HOU - exp hitting
17. bontomm - HOU - EXP pitching (proxy)
18. Thomasmore - Ny Giants pre hitting
19. Musial6 - TEX - EXP hitting
20. rburgh - Mon Exp Pitching
21. NYMETS99 - Det Pre Hitting
22. krazykat - Philadelphia A, Deadball Era Pitching
23. reggie reigns - Cleveland DB pitching
24. mrharryc - Atlanta EXP pitching

RD3

25. mrharryc - Milwaukee (Braves) hitting
26. reggie reigns - Brooklyn -Post hitting
27. krazykat - Oakland, Expansion Era Pitching
28. NYMETS99-post Brooklyn pitching
29. rburgh - CLE EXP Pitching
30. Musial6 - NYY - EXP - Pitching
31. Thomasmore - Orioles Post Hitting
32. bontomn - Twins EXP hitting (proxy)
33. sschu - KC-exp Hitting
34. treyomo - As DB hitting
35. JOEYC - Yankees Expansion Hitting
36. FrankMansueto - Pitt DB Pitching

Rd. 4
13. FrankMansueto - Wash DB Pitching
14. JOEYC - BOS pre hitting
15. treyomo - PHI DB hitting
16. ssch - LA-exp hitting
17. bontomm - CWS Exp -- Hitting
18. Thomasmore - CHC Exp Pitching
19. Musial6 - CLE - Post - Pitching
20. rburgh -
21. NYMETS99 -
22. krazykat -
23. reggie reigns -
24. mrharryc


Which means Satchel Paige is mine!!!! "So don't any of you homo (sapiens) be touching him!" Francis from Stripes.

His More expensive card is eligible in the fa draft

No way man - he's on the Cleveland Post Roster. I know it was never stated one way or the other but originally there was not to be any NELs or free agents, so he was locked in to the Cleveland Post roster at that time. In any franchise I've ever participated in that's always been the case.

rburgh, please don't make your pick until this is resolved, because if it's not the case, or the general consensus goes against this common practice, I want to make another choice!!!!

I think this is exactly like the alex rodriguez example made earlier. If ny exp was picked , and rangers werent than he was avialable to be drafted as a Free Agent. I think that since we made all other players available - including NEL- prior to any possible controversy , than the ruling should apply to all.

No - I disagree - it's not the same and I cite earlier and numerous franchise leagues where Paige always belongs to the Cleveland franchise, if chosen, and Paige is not a free agent. NELs are NOT an eligible franchise in this league. In the Rodriguez example Texas is an eligible franchise. I think that makes a big difference - especially in trying to choose a competitive franchise for pitching.

No - I disagree - it's not the same and I cite earlier and numerous franchise leagues where Paige always belongs to the Cleveland franchise, if chosen, and Paige is not a free agent. NELs are NOT an eligible franchise in this league. In the Rodriguez example Texas is an eligible franchise. I think that makes a big difference - especially in trying to choose a competitive franchise for pitching.

If anyone else can support your argument than Paige is yours. If not my ruling stands

I went back in the thread and reviewed the issue of the 1-round single player draft. There was some mention early about including NeL players for that, but as far as I know the issue of the NeL players was never really resolved.

As far as Musial's argument goes, I think the 1-round player draft makes this unlike any of the other leagues that have been run where people drafted franchises only. But I'm just one voice, and don't feel strongly one way or the other.

I can see his point, but not sure how significant it is to all. Suggest the commish make the decision and Musial can repick if he wants. Lets keep it moving.

sschu

I must admit I was thinking of taking Cleveland Post with my back to back picks. Passed on them because I was under the impression that Satchel could be picked in the FA Round. Understood it the way the A-Rod issue was explained.

I can see his point, but not sure how significant it is to all. Suggest the commish make the decision and Musial can repick if he wants. Lets keep it moving.

sschu

I think Musial should repick . I'm sorry if this isn't what you want to hear but I think that it's fair

I went back in the thread and reviewed the issue of the 1-round single player draft. There was some mention early about including NeL players for that, but as far as I know the issue of the NeL players was never really resolved.

As far as Musial's argument goes, I think the 1-round player draft makes this unlike any of the other leagues that have been run where people drafted franchises only. But I'm just one voice, and don't feel strongly one way or the other.

I guess I had assumed that the NEL players were available for the 1 round supplemental pick, but after reading the above I'm confused. Will the NEL player pool be available for the supplemental draft?

JoeyC

It appears to me, from the commish"s statement that Musial should repick, that the NeL player pool will be available. But we should have clarity.