Thanks For The Help...with... Kiner or Duffy

This is my first ATG team in several years and only my 2nd or 3rd try maybe. This roster is still a work in progress, I have to choose between Ralph Kiner and Hugh Duffy, as well as choosing between Bill Robinson or Lou Pinella versus LHP. Royals 1980 is my park. Here is the roster:

http://onlinegames.strat-o-matic.com/team/1381630

Please, feel free to pick this team apart, tell me how bad you think it is. Even though the roster is still a work in progress this is pretty much what I am working with. The league has some great GMs and my division is mostly small ball or singles' parks and there are several other singles' parks and pitchers' parks throughout the league. No one seems to be stocking up on too many HR hitters.

I would be greatly appreciative of any comments, even negative feedback. I really value most of your opinions!

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR ANY COMMENTS OR CRITIQUES!

Keep Kiner you can use the power. Other than that it looks OK.

duffy all the way. lot better d and obp plus he want slow your team down on the bases. i'd also go with the 94 gwynn or another rf. assume you're going to leadoff with garr then lofton then i'd go duffy,etc.

is this an ATG 8 team?

if its the 8 see if the 1927 smith is available

i'd use the 73 carew at 2b and get sisler or terry for 1b or better yet the new chance

Duffy over Kiner

Thanks for all the replies! I have thought about using the 1973 Carew at 2B, and I still might.

Scorehouse asked

is this an ATG 8 team?

Yes it is ATG 8 I am pretty sure Chino Smith has been taken

I've had good luck with that cheap Piniella card in a platoon either LF or DH

http://latorrer0.tripod.com/pictureslinks/kiner_vs_duffy.png