hackra wrote:Valen,
I disagree with you that this is not used intentionally to gain advantage. I think this happens frequently.
One way it could be used (I have only seen this once that I recall). - A team has the $ to keep the expensive Pedro Martinez on his squad, but uses the cheaper but more effective non* Pedro in game 1. They drop him and replace him with the most expensive Pedro at 9:01 eastern. Then use him to start game 4.
Another way I see used frequently -
A team "Hordes" several specific players on their team in extra roster spots (such as the scrub version of Hugh Duffy) to limit access to these guys. Then at 9:01 eastern time there is a flurry of drops with a preplanned add. This does keep others from using these players in the preseason and forces the drop penalty on anyone who wished to pick them up. It could still be done at 8:59 eastern time I suppose....but it bugs me every time those managers are not charged a drop penalty.
I really wish Strat would implement a Roster lock at least 2 hours before game time on opening day to remove this issue.
I actually think it would make it worse to "close the loophole" relative to how it is now. Right now with the limbo period after 10 Eastern, people have to drop players they are hoarding, e.g. Hugh Duffy, shortly after 10 or risk having them on their team or pay the drop/add penalty. If there was a hard cutoff of say, 8 PM, then these same managers would do their drops at 7:59 and effectively burn these players for the rest of the league.
I had a guy in my division in a 140M league who was playing in a lefty park with a bunch of lefty starters. He carried Gehrig and Bagwell throughout the preseason and dropped Bagwell at 9:59 on Monday night. He became very irked because I was able to pick him up in the limbo period after 10:00.