ATG 8 Player Addition #3 Nomination Thread

excuse my spelling - its Pat Hentgen

I've already nominated, but if you haven't yet and would like to help add some middle infielders who can also help franchise leagues, think about nominating:
2003 or 2004 Mark Loretta San Diego 2b
1998 Ray Durham Chicago White Sox 2b
1989 Greg Gagne Minnesota SS

Respectfully agree that we DO NOT NEED the 2002 Magglio Ordonez card.

Again, I don't understand the concept of getting a player's 2nd or 3rd best card. Unless that player is an absolute superstar.

The 2007 Ordonez card is the card that needs to be added.




Jose Reyes 2011 ( To help the NY Mets instead of freakin Harrelson)


Reyes is my vote, the Magglio statement is just that. His 2007 card excels.

Dustin Pedroia 2008
Vinny Castilla 1998
Dante Bichette 1995
Luis Gonzalez 2001

To add to Andy's comment, these guys help the lesser franchises.

Visick-

I nominated the Pedroia card already
and Bill took care of the other one I think is important which is
the 2012 Buster Posey card.

Not that Im against any of these or the ones Andy is mentioning.
They are all good.

Thanks Salty...

I love that Posey card, but IMO don't really think we need it right now.

Ya got Dietz, Smith, Snyder, Haller etc... All have spent time with SF/NY Giants.

I didn't go through all the pages. Pedroia is a nice addition, but BOS already has Doerr.


I would like to see players added that can immediately help the franchises that desperately need players.
ie. Arizona/Colorado etc...

I voted for Reyes on the Mets, because they need someone other than Buddy @ SS.


Please vote wisely guys... If you're gonna vote for someone, let it be their best year. Like I said awhile back, Gary Carter is my favorite all time Met. We didn't need his card added. We already had a good card.

The Mets Reyes card. (2011)

1999 Luis Castillo

Ross Barnes 1873

31 doubles, 11 triples in only 340 AB. .431/.465/.616

1989 Jeff Russell ...Rangers RP.....9th inCY Young Voting that year