Negro Leagues vs MLB *MLB Draft time*

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 -
65. Modmark -
66. BDWard -

Offline
andycummings65
Posts: 2662
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 9:42 pm
Re: Negro Leagues vs MLB *MLB Draft time*
Unread postWed Apr 29, 2015 8:51 am

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 - Joe Page
65. Modmark -
66. BDWard -

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 - Joe Page
65. Modmark - Johnny Vander Meer (by proxy)
66. BDWard -

ROUND 12 - Final round for top 4 SP's/Top 8 Position players
55. BDWard -
56. Modmark -
57. lanier64 -
58. rburgh -
59. andycummings65 -
60. Musial6 -

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 - Joe Page Please repick, RP in a separate draft with the NeL clubs.
65. Modmark - Johnny Vander Meer (by proxy)
66. BDWard -

ROUND 12 - Final round for top 4 SP's/Top 8 Position players
55. BDWard -
56. Modmark -
57. lanier64 -
58. rburgh -
59. andycummings65 -
60. Musial6 -

This is, without a doubt the biggest pain in the butt I have ever experienced in the eight years I have been playing ATG. Three different and very long threads to review. Long lists of excepted players. Fuzzy, vague and overly complicated rules that's seem to change constantly. Arbitrary limitations placed on half of the players on the league. If I were not a man of my word I would bail out of this ridiculous mess. And no, I don't need or want a comment or a scolding by the commissioner or anyone else. I just need to vent.

I normally love theme leagues and have no problem with restrictions as long as they make sense and ARE EASY TO FOLLOW. But this has gone horribly wrong.

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 - Rube Benton
65. Modmark - Johnny Vander Meer (by proxy)
66. BDWard -

ROUND 12 - Final round for top 4 SP's/Top 8 Position players
55. BDWard -
56. Modmark -
57. lanier64 -
58. rburgh -
59. andycummings65 -
60. Musial6 -

Well then you're really going to love this...
Rube Benton would be your 5th SP, we are currently only drafting 4. The 5th SP will be in the RP draft. In addition his qualifying 1921 card is a RP card so if you want him he'll be available in that draft. His other 1912 SP card falls outside the 1920 - 1955 years to be eligible.

According to my spreadsheet you need a 2b and SS. Please select one of those positions, tks.

I appreciate your participation and patience in regards to this concept. I've tried to be extremely transparent in my vision for this League. Sorry you feel that it hasn't met with your expectations. I hope you still have fun.

Rosie

Well, actually Lanier just needs 2 infielder s, since Frisch can play anywhere.

Andy and I need catchers, Musial needs a 2B, and Mark (1) and Bernie (2) need SP.

I guess I can go ahead and draft Bill Delancey.

Ah right, tks rburgh...my spreadsheet doesn't have the anywhere position listed out.

My Roster

Delancey, Bill SLC 1934 4.27
Camilli, Dolph BRK 1938 5.60
Stanky, Eddie NYG 1950 6.14
Mathews, Eddie MBV 1953 8.00
Vaughan, Arky PIT 1935 10.20
Goslin, Goose SLB 1930 5.20
Averill, Earl CLE 1934 7.71
Youngs, Ross NYG 1920 7.26
Russo, Marius NYY 1939 7.43
Lanier, Max SLC 1946 7.08
Beggs, Joe CIN 1946 5.05
Baumgartner, Stan PHA 1924 3.01
76.95

ROUND 1
1. Musial6 - Babe Ruth - Briggs Stadium '41
2. Andycummings65 - Rogers Hornsby - Forbes '54
3. rburgh - Arky Vaughan - Dunn Field '20
4. lanier64 - Stan Musial - Ebbets Field '20
5. Modmark - Jimmy Foxx - Shibe '41 (AL)
6. BDWard - Ted Williams - League Park '34

ROUND 2
7. BDWard - Duke Snider - $9.66
8. Modmark - Al Simmons - 9.73
9. lanier64 - Mel Ott - 9.05
10. rburgh - Eddie Mathews
11. andycummings65 - Lou Boudreau
12. Musial6 - Hack Wilson

ROUND 3
13. Musial6 - Joe Medwick
14. andycummings - Kiki Cuyler
15. rburgh - Earl Averill
16. lanier64 - Zack Wheat
17. Modmark - Gabby Hartnett
18. BDWard - Bill Dickey

ROUND 4
19. BDWard - Luke Appling
20. Modmark - Hank Greenberg
21. lanier64 - Frank Frisch
22. rburgh - Marius Russo
23. andycummings65 - Kirby Higbe
24. Musial6 - Yogi Berra

ROUND 5
25. Musial6 - Vern Stephens
26. andycummings - Tex Hughson
27. rburgh - Max Lanier
28. lanier64 - Carl Hubbell
29. Modmark - Carl Furillo
30. BDWard - Ted Kluszewski

ROUND 6
31. BDWard - Nellie Fox
32. Modmark - Tony Lazzeri
33. lanier64 - Schoolboy Rowe
34. rburgh - Dolph Camilli
35. andycummings65- Riggs Stephenson
36. Musial6 - Johnny Mize

ROUND 7
37. Musial6 - Al Rosen
38. andycummings - Dom DiMaggio
39. rburgh - Goose Goslin
40. lanier64 - Hippo Vaughn
41. Modmark - Del Ennis
42. BDWard - George Selkirk

ROUND 8
43. BDWard - Cecil Travis
44. Modmark - Frank Crosetti
45. lanier64 - Ed Brandt
46. rburgh - Ross Youngs
47. andycummings65 - Baby Doll JAcobson
48. Musial6 - Red Munger

ROUND 9
49. Musial6 - Harry Gumbert
50. andycummings65 - Bobby Thomson
51. rburgh - Eddie Stanky
52. lanier64 - Del Rice
53. Modmark - Mort Cooper
54. BDWard - Ken Raffensberger

ROUND 10
55. BDWard - Howard Ehmke
56. Modmark - George Earnshaw
57. lanier64 - Pete Reiser
58. rburgh - Stan Baumgartner, SP card
59. andycummings65 - Tommy Bridges SP
60. Musial6 - Sal Maglie

ROUND11
61. Musial6 - Howie Pollet
62. andycummings65 - Mike Garcia
63. rburgh - Joe Beggs
64. lanier64 - Rube Benton
65. Modmark - Johnny Vander Meer (by proxy)
66. BDWard - Harvey Haddix

ROUND 12 - Final round for top 4 SP's/Top 8 Position players
55. BDWard - Ellis Kinder
56. Modmark -
57. lanier64 -
58. rburgh -
59. andycummings65 -
60. Musial6 -