HCKL Prospect Draft 2015 Rnds 4 & 5

Palm can starts us off anytime.

R4
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver
R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver
R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

Is this picked allowed? Has played in MLB this year, but not last? Just clarifying as to update my list if it is.

Is this picked allowed? Has played in MLB this year, but not last? Just clarifying as to update my list if it is.

Should be, if this league sues the rules most others do, and I believe it does, so long as he had no MLB experience prior to the current MLB season, he's eligible. It's been said before how summer prospect draft picks can be more valuable than Spring picks, especially if they come very late in the MLB season, and this is why. I'm pretty sure this is the way we've done it in this league too/

Of course qksilver could come on and refute this and checking the rules I see this:

All players who have not played in MLB are eligible for the prospect draft including unsigned US or international amateurs.

so there is no mention of summer picks using the same criteria, and I can see how an argument can be made to not allow it.

Editing order to reflect Smitty/Lev deal.

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Smitty (from Lev)
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

All players who have not played in MLB are eligible for the prospect draft including unsigned US or international amateurs.

so there is no mention of summer picks using the same criteria, and I can see how an argument can be made to not allow it.[/quote]

Yes summer picks same as spring - if no MLB experience prior to 2015 they are eligible.

Editing order to reflect Smitty/Lev deal.

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig - Osuna, Roberto RP TOR
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Smitty (from Lev)
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig - (REPICK OSUNA ON MY PROSPECT ROSTER)
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Smitty (from Lev)
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig - Jungmann, Taylor SP MIL
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Smitty (from Lev)
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R4
Palmtana - McCullers, Lance SP HOU
Craig - Jungmann, Taylor SP MIL
Cubit - Barreto, Franklin SS OAK
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Smitty (from Lev)
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver

R5
Palmtana
Craig
Cubit
Smitty
Hawk
Stoney
Zim
Lev
Ninersphan
Smokey
Fowldawg
Qksilver