Clemente 68 or 72 vs Winfield in Shea

http://onlinegames.strat-o-matic.com/te ... ht/1412733

Off to 10-5 start above at Shea;
Clemente injury has him in 68 or 72 - worst yrs. (LHP heavy is favoring 72)
STD, my LHB's Carew, Yaz, Kemp are on fire - no reads; also have Nettles (looks like low BA card) and Porter, Mays is split R
Only Yaz and Clemente

Clemente will provide good OBP, but no power. Winfield is available, but concerned about Shea.

Would you suggest dropping Clemente for Winfield, or be satisfied with Clemente's OBP?

Tough call, but, I'd keep Clemente. You've likely got the 4th best Clemente card, which makes it tempting to try Winfield, but, you've only got a 40% chance (two out of five Winfield's years over .300, with power) you'll be happy if you do it. Plus, Winfield might only hit 18-20 homers instead of 25-35, even if you get one of his two best years.

However, Clemente's injury rating is likely a '3', so, that improves your chances that you'll be happier with Winfield, I'm guessing there is a 45-50% chance you'll be happier with Winfield than Clemente, all things considered.

Tough call, but, I'd keep Clemente. You've likely got the 4th best Clemente card, which makes it tempting to try Winfield, but, you've only got a 40% chance (two out of five Winfield's years over .300, with power) you'll be happy if you do it. Plus, Winfield might only hit 18-20 homers instead of 25-35, even if you get one of his two best years.

However, Clemente's injury rating is likely a '3', so, that improves your chances that you'll be happier with Winfield, I'm guessing there is a 45-50% chance you'll be happier with Winfield than Clemente, all things considered.

Went with Winfield....
Didn't feel comfortable having any power vs. LHP, and the Clemente injuries were an issue......

[quote][/quote]

Winfield was a heavy-lefty disaster.... took Clemente back.
Cost me $$, but the seasons early and Clemente will give me consistant OBP and hit LHP which is my weakside so far.