- Posts: 2123
- Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 1:44 am
I understand that sphilipp may think this is unfair, but I need to comment on the Giant's protected list. There is no need to protect Herbel or Jesus Alou because it is extremely unlikely that the Astros will select these duds. The Giants should consider protecting WIlhelm and Dietz since they could likely trade their rights in the preseason or any time during the season.
Wilhelm is the best reliever in the whole league. Dietz is the 4th most expensive catcher and due to the limited availability of players, there will be fewer cap issues than in a regular season. It's just my opinion, but I didn't envision top players being available in the expansion draft.
I respect sphilipp. He's a great player and he's very fair. I'm not trying to hurt his team but I'm trying to get a reasonably realistic expansion draft.