Is this an offer or a conversation????

would you consider this a trade offer or not?

"Most I am offering for Mesoraco alone is
4th FA for Mesoraco and 8th FA"

come on now folks I can see you are looking at this thread
a simple yes or no is all I ask
this survey is for my own private satisfaction or regret

depends, now that the ratings are out I'd have to see what his look like.

depends, now that the ratings are out I'd have to see what his look like.

Can not answer trade questions like this in a vacuum. Need to know the make up of the teams, who is "going for it" who is building, how high the draft pick is. etc

I like Mesoraco, one of the few catchers with power. So, if it's at all close, I would not do it, ie I'd have to be blown away to trade him

let me rephrase

I am not asking about whether you or I should make this trade
but if someone typed these words to you in a PM
would you consider it an offer or a conversation leading up to an offer......

let me rephrase

I am not asking about whether you or I should make this trade
but if someone typed these words to you in a PM
would you consider it an offer or a conversation leading up to an offer......

not an official offer

let me rephrase

I am not asking about whether you or I should make this trade
but if someone typed these words to you in a PM
would you consider it an offer or a conversation leading up to an offer......

I would ask for confirmation.

I would ask for clarification.

I agree - it's fuzzy would confirm it was an actual offer.