90s keepers season 18 keeper list and question

Roberto Alomar
Moises Alou
Jeff Bagwell
Craig Biggio
Wade Boggs
Barry Bonds
Kevin Brown (P)
Brett Butler
Jose Canseco
Vinny Castilla
Roger Clemens (P)
Nomar Garciaparra
Brian Giles
Tom Glavine (P)
Ken Griffey Jr
Rickey Henderson
Derek Jeter
Chipper Jones
Randy Johnson (P)
Kenny Lofton
Greg Maddux (P)
Edgar Martinez
Pedro Martinez (P)
Mark McGuire
Kevin Mitchell
Mike Mussina (P)
Rey Ordonez
Mike Piazza
Kirby Puckett
Jose Rijo (P)
Frank Thomas
Jim Thome
Manny Ramirez
Alex Rodriguez
Larry Walker
Bernie Williams


In season 17 we discussed doing a live draft instead of a supplemental.
I say we put it to a vote so post your opinion below. If we do a live draft we will have to also discuss how we do stadium changes.

We can do the supplemental/stadium round the same as always, on the forum here. Then each players first 4 picks on the live draft are his 3 keepers plus his supplemental pick. I am in favor of live draft. Do we just go with random draft order? Or can we customize it?

houstonmetfan -
durantjerry -
edwardneal63 -
nol15736 -
joeddrott - live
falcon29 - live
jimmy_c - live
jayhawk81 - live
icterus galbuli - live
bigamcinroy - live
exwallman -
fatdaddy054 -

I took the liberty of going over our thread from the league and added any who have voted. If you have changed your mind or I have made an error please update accordingly.

We can do the supplemental/stadium round the same as always, on the forum here. Then each players first 4 picks on the live draft are his 3 keepers plus his supplemental pick. I am in favor of live draft. Do we just go with random draft order? Or can we customize it?

houstonmetfan - Live
durantjerry -
edwardneal63 -
nol15736 -
joeddrott - live
falcon29 - live
jimmy_c - live
jayhawk81 - live
icterus galbuli - live
bigamcinroy - live
exwallman -
fatdaddy054 -

I took the liberty of going over our thread from the league and added any who have voted. If you have changed your mind or I have made an error please update accordingly.

We can do the supplemental/stadium round the same as always, on the forum here. Then each players first 4 picks on the live draft are his 3 keepers plus his supplemental pick. I am in favor of live draft. Do we just go with random draft order? Or can we customize it?

houstonmetfan - Live
durantjerry -
edwardneal63 (Ed2014) - forum but live is okay if that is preferred
nol15736 -
joeddrott - live
falcon29 - live
jimmy_c - live
jayhawk81 - live
icterus galbuli - live
bigamcinroy - live
exwallman -
fatdaddy054 -

I took the liberty of going over our thread from the league and added any who have voted. If you have changed your mind or I have made an error please update accordingly.

I can do a lot of live draft too.

Exwallman

houstonmetfan - Live
durantjerry -
ed2014 - live
nol15736 -
joeddrott - live
falcon29 - live
jimmy_c - live
jayhawk81 - live
icterus galbuli - live
bigamcinroy - live
exwallman - live
fatdaddy054 -

to be clear the forum draft is only for the first four rounds. The choice is live draft or auto draft. Slow live on the forum was not one of the options.

I'm currently en route to India on a business trip and won't be back until the middle of next month. Doing a live draft from there is going to be very problematic. Sorry guys. If you want to replace me and move on, I get it, but I enjoy this league and don't really want to give it up. If you come up with an agreeable time for everyone else, let me know and I'll see what I can do.

I don't think we should penalize Falcon for having to work. I'd love to do a live draft as well, but with him being gone til next month why don't we do our supplemental and auto draft this season, and then hopefully by the end of next season we can come up with a live draft time for season 19?

Roberto Alomar
Moises Alou
Jeff Bagwell
Craig Biggio
Wade Boggs
Barry Bonds
Kevin Brown (P)
Brett Butler
Jose Canseco
Vinny Castilla
Roger Clemens (P)
Nomar Garciaparra
Brian Giles
Tom Glavine (P)
Ken Griffey Jr
Rickey Henderson
Derek Jeter
Chipper Jones
Randy Johnson (P)
Kenny Lofton
Greg Maddux (P)
Edgar Martinez
Pedro Martinez (P)
Mark McGuire
Kevin Mitchell
Mike Mussina (P)
Rey Ordonez
Mike Piazza
Kirby Puckett
Jose Rijo (P)
Frank Thomas
Jim Thome
Manny Ramirez
Alex Rodriguez
Larry Walker
Bernie Williams


1. Joeedrott
2.fatdaddy054
3.edwardneal63
4.falcon29
5.jimmyc
6.exwallman
7.jayhawk81
8.durantjerry
9.bigamcinroy
10.houstonmetfan
11-12. Pending finals

Middle of next month is ok with me.