- Posts: 273
- Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 6:23 pm
As you already noted EVERYONE has a great team on paper. There is more of a fine line between success and failure. Experience and ability to make Hal do what you want is important. Matching players to ballpark matters a lot. That allows you to maybe get a little more out of that $9 mil you paid someone than the other guy gets from his $9 mil guy.
Depending on your cap you may need to adjust your thinking. A lineup full of .380 OBP guys may have been great in 20xx but given allstar pitching staffs that gets downsized fast and may even be overmatched by the other guy having a lineup full of .450 OBP guys. Ditto slugging. Put 3 .550 SLG guys in middle of a 20xx lineup and you may have something. Put 3 guys like that in an ATG lineup and the other guy counters with 3 or more .700 SLG guys and life gets difficult.
I think ATG is more about identifying how a lineup fits together more than in 20xx. There is no shortage of good players. Making sure the players complement each other and everything is maximized as much as possible is important. Creativity can help.
Last but not least spend some time looking through the player list. Good chance your better teams will have multiple players you never heard of before you started looking.