Reelin' in the Years League - Season 35

{{PROSPECT ROUND 1}} * * * NO CLOCK IN 1ST ROUND * * *
1. jflatour99 (from Meat) - Dansby Swanson SS Atl.
2. bigmahon (from tcochran) - Benintendi, Andrew OF BOS
3. alk58
4. Turtle
5. gbrookes (from willmurr24)
6. jflatour99
7. jflatour99 (from padrenurgle1)
8. bigmahon (from CATom/dharmabums)
9. bigmahon
10. gbrookes
11. JMP1
12. zim13

* * * 2-HOUR CLOCK, 10AM - 10PM EDT, 7 DAYS PER WEEK * * *

{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
13. zim13
14. JMP1
15. padrenurgle1 (from gbrookes)
16. dharmabums (from bigmahon)
17. dharmabums
18. padrenurgle1
19. jflatour99
20. willmurr24
21. Turtle
22. alk58
23. bigmahon (from tcochran)
24. Meat

Benny Baseball was my pick, will take offers for next pick in draft

Benny Baseball was my pick, will take offers for next pick in draft

pm sent

bigmahon trades prospect picks #9 and #23

To alk58 for prospect pick #3

alk to confirm

bigmahon trades prospect picks #9 and #23

To alk58 for prospect pick #3

alk to confirm

confirm

{{PROSPECT ROUND 1}} * * * NO CLOCK IN 1ST ROUND * * *
1. jflatour99 (from Meat) - Dansby Swanson SS Atl.
2. bigmahon (from tcochran) - Benintendi, Andrew OF BOS
3. bigmahon (from akl58) - Arcia, Orlando SS MIL
4. Turtle
5. gbrookes (from willmurr24)
6. jflatour99
7. jflatour99 (from padrenurgle1)
8. bigmahon (from CATom/dharmabums)
9. alk58 (from bigmahon)
10. gbrookes
11. JMP1
12. zim13

* * * 2-HOUR CLOCK, 10AM - 10PM EDT, 7 DAYS PER WEEK * * *

{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
13. zim13
14. JMP1
15. padrenurgle1 (from gbrookes)
16. dharmabums (from bigmahon)
17. dharmabums
18. padrenurgle1
19. jflatour99
20. willmurr24
21. Turtle
22. alk58
23. alk58 (from bigmahon/tcochran)
24. Meat

is 23 a valid pick to trade? wouldn't that have been 5th prospect?

So if I trade one of my first 3 picks the 4th one becomes valid again?

Yes, as long as the trade occurs before you are holding 4 prospects

The commish has already ruled on this.

im not looking to be an a-hole, but I've been slapped on this with late FA picks, and my understanding is that would have been before the benny baseball pick which gave u two prospects, and three existing picks.

im not looking to be an a-hole, but I've been slapped on this with late FA picks, and my understanding is that would have been before the benny baseball pick which gave u two prospects, and three existing picks.

This has been a [frustrating] discussion in a number of leagues and it is my interpretation that all picks are valid until they are not -- see previous posts for rationale