Community - Get into the Card Discussions!

Does anyone know if there is a list of whole teams in ATG without reconstructing it?

Although that is how All-Time Greats was constituted when it began (through at least ATG3 or ATG4 as I recall), no there is not a list of teams. One would have to compile that list individually.

Hey tcochran - shall we start a separate post regarding the Negro Leagues?

Hey tcochran - shall we start a separate post regarding the Negro Leagues?

Could we please just focus on major league players?

Hey tcochran - shall we start a separate post regarding the Negro Leagues?

Could we please just focus on major league players?

No doubt that's the focus but tcochran and I both signed up for the NeL so just getting that conversation started. Highly unlikely that amounts to any adds for this or the next many, but when it does man will we be ready.

Other than formulating enough RP-onlys for a squad, aren't more NeL cards redundant? It was my understanding that the NeL cards we have now are amalgamations of several seasons into an average card for each NeL player. If they are already representative of the player's career, aren't they as redundant as a 6th Babe Ruth card?

Here are some Diamondbacks/Rays Player Starter Selections:
Arizona Diamondbacks:
Tony Clark-1B 2005
Paul Goldsmidt-1B 2015
Stephen Drew-SS 2008
Steve Finley-CF 2000
Brandon Webb-SP 2006(Cy Young)
Byung-Hyun Kim-RP 2002

Tampa Bay Rays:
Carlos Pena-1B 2007
Fred Mcgriff-1B 1999
Evan Longoria-3B 2009
Carl Crawford-LF 2010
James Shield-SP 2011
David Price-SP 2012
Grany Balfour-RP 2008

Additional Missing/Upgrade Possibilties:
Miquel Cabrera-3B 2013(Triple Crown)
Garret Anderson-LF LAA 2003
Brendan Donnelly-RP LAA 2003
Jose Mesa-RP CLE 1995
Vernon Wells-CF TOR 2003
Willie Stargell-OF/1B PIT 1973
BJ Ryan-RP TOR 2006 or BAL 2005
Mike Trout-OF LAA 2012(ROY)
Jose Bautista-RF TOR 2011
Dave Parker-RF PIT 1978
Fred Mcgriff-1B ATL 1994 or SDP 1992
Dale Murphy-OF ATL 1985
Manny Ramirez-RF CLE 1999
Jake Peavy-SP SDP 2007(Cy Young)

This is a starter list for this endeavor. Feel free to add.

I really like that Granny Balfour guy.

Reminder that most of this work has already been done by Bill. There's got to be a way to incorporate his gargantuan effort into the card addition process.

Pitchers:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... li=1#gid=0

Batters:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... li=1#gid=0

While I'm happy to get new cards period, I think the biggest need is in the cheap bench player/ 50 cent 1 side reliever area to fill out teams at the lower caps.

I realize these players aren't as exciting but they are needed.